App Scam DBBY ALEX KLEBER
← ALL INVESTIGATIONS
Notion look-alike branding and privacy warning · Productivity

Four paid Mac apps borrow Notion’s identity. The privacy documents tell another story.

Four paid Mac apps put “for Notion” in their names and a prominent black-and-white N in their icons. Their combined names, artwork and promotional use of Notion’s logo can make independent subscriptions look like official Notion products. The four sellers use different Apple accounts. Static analysis confirms real Notion integration, while the documents expose a contact-only privacy link, policies for other products and AI processing that users need explained clearly.

VISUAL EVIDENCE

Start with the closest visual imitations of Notion

Awais Mobeen’s tilted frame and serif N closely echo Notion’s cube-and-letter identity. Muhammad Abait adds a thick frame and sync badge. These original Apple images show recognisable borrowing with visible differences; the assessment concerns the icon, name and marketing together. The next comparison covers the other two sellers. E2/E4/E20.

Task & Todo for Notion · Awais MobeenOriginal current Apple icon: tilted frame, large serif N and two underline strokes. E20.
Original current Apple icon: tilted frame, large serif N and two underline strokes. E20.
Official Notion · Notion LabsOriginal official Notion mobile-app icon, used as the brand reference. Apple-hosted image retrieved 21 November 2026. E4.
Original official Notion mobile-app icon, used as the brand reference. Apple-hosted image retrieved 21 November 2026. E4.
Todo List:Workspace For Notion · Muhammad AbaitOriginal current Apple icon: framed N with sync badge. E2.
Original current Apple icon: framed N with sync badge. E2.
Official Notion · Notion LabsOriginal official Notion mobile-app icon, used as the brand reference. Apple-hosted image retrieved 21 November 2026. E4.
Original official Notion mobile-app icon, used as the brand reference. Apple-hosted image retrieved 21 November 2026. E4.

Two more versions of the same Notion-led identity

Arshad uses a serif N with two underline strokes. App Sensor uses a rounded sans-serif N on a clipboard, so its letterform is less similar than the others. Its Notion-led title and prominent Notion badge in the first promotion still place Notion’s identity at the centre of the sales pitch. Neither resemblance nor use of a compatibility badge alone proves fraud.

Todo List & App for Notion · Waleed ArshadSerif N with two underline strokes; original Apple icon. E3.
Serif N with two underline strokes; original Apple icon. E3.
Official Notion · Notion LabsOriginal official Notion mobile-app icon, used as the brand reference. Apple-hosted image retrieved 21 November 2026. E4.
Original official Notion mobile-app icon, used as the brand reference. Apple-hosted image retrieved 21 November 2026. E4.
Todo & Tasks for Notion · App SensorClipboard containing a rounded N; original Apple icon. The different letterform is preserved. E19.
Clipboard containing a rounded N; original Apple icon. The different letterform is preserved. E19.
Official Notion · Notion LabsOriginal official Notion mobile-app icon, used as the brand reference. Apple-hosted image retrieved 21 November 2026. E4.
Original official Notion mobile-app icon, used as the brand reference. Apple-hosted image retrieved 21 November 2026. E4.

Original current Apple artwork and official Notion reference. E3/E4/E19.

Four publisher accounts and their verified products

Apple identifies four different publishers: Muhammad Abait (6825284962), Waleed Arshad (6776619521), App Sensor / APP SENSOR LLP (6790821136), and Awais Mobeen (1793533465). The diagrams show products joined by the exact same Apple developer ID. No shared-owner arrow joins the four accounts.

The current US lookups return two products for Abait, two for Arshad, five for App Sensor and six for Mobeen. Abait’s Uniqly remains a preorder. Companion products are account inventory, not automatically accused apps; they have not all undergone binary testing.

Verified same-account connections, Apple developer IDs, app IDs and original app icons. Abait’s Uniqly is a preorder; Arshad’s chatbot is a separate product. No shared owner between the two accounts was established. E10/E11/E12.
Verified same-account connections, Apple developer IDs, app IDs and original app icons. Abait’s Uniqly is a preorder; Arshad’s chatbot is a separate product. No shared owner between the two accounts was established. E10/E11/E12.
App Sensor and Awais Mobeen: all products returned by current Apple publisher lookups, with original icons. Arrows mean the same publisher ID; no cross-account ownership is asserted. E25/E26.
App Sensor and Awais Mobeen: all products returned by current Apple publisher lookups, with original icons. Arrows mean the same publisher ID; no cross-account ownership is asserted. E25/E26.
Muhammad Abait’s Apple account Waleed Arshad’s Apple account Todo List:Workspace For Notion · Abait Todo List & App for Notion · Arshad App Sensor · Apple developer 6790821136 Awais Mobeen · Apple developer 1793533465

E10/E11/E25/E26: Apple account inventories. E12/E18/E27: static and historical cross-checks, with common SDK markers excluded.

Apple rules this evidence puts in question

Apple should review the combined naming and icon presentation of all four apps. The clearest document failures are Arshad’s contact-only privacy link and Mobeen’s terms naming Invitation Maker instead of this task app. These are evidence-based compliance concerns, not an Apple enforcement decision.

Specific rules and the evidence Apple can verify
RuleApplication to this case
2.3 / 2.3.1 · Accurate presentationAssess the Notion-led identities against the actual independent sellers. E2/E3/E19/E20.
2.3.7 · Names and keywordsAssess third-party names alongside the N-based icons and promotional branding. E2/E3/E19/E20.
4.1 / 5.2.1 · Copycats and intellectual propertyCheck the visual identity and each seller’s authorisation; preserve the differing App Sensor clipboard design. E4/E14/E19/E20.
5.1.1(i) · Privacy policyContact-only privacy link, CodeFuse document and Invitation Maker terms. E7/E9/E24. The terms issue also concerns accurate documentation under 2.3.
5.1.2(i) · Data sharingReview app-specific disclosure and consent for AI data paths; no missing-consent finding is established. E8/E9.
1.6 · Data securityReview Arshad’s client-side AI-key loading design; live exposure was not tested. E9.
Read Apple’s official rules

Current Apple App Review Guidelines, checked 21 November 2026. E13.

Download full dossier · PDF ↓
LOOK FOR YOURSELF

The screenshots tell the story.

Original Apple-hosted first promotions from all four sellers appear below; expand the full galleries for the remaining images. They advertise Notion compatibility using its name, wordmark and cube/badge. A compatibility badge can be legitimate; the assessment concerns the overall independent product identity.

See all 18 additional screenshots
Original Apple-hosted promotional image 2 for app 6787069755. Marketing evidence, not a runtime test. E20.
Original Apple-hosted promotional image 2 for app 6787069755. Marketing evidence, not a runtime test. E20.
Original Apple-hosted promotional image 3 for app 6787069755. Marketing evidence, not a runtime test. E20.
Original Apple-hosted promotional image 3 for app 6787069755. Marketing evidence, not a runtime test. E20.
Original Apple-hosted promotional image 4 for app 6787069755. Marketing evidence, not a runtime test. E20.
Original Apple-hosted promotional image 4 for app 6787069755. Marketing evidence, not a runtime test. E20.
Original Apple-hosted promotion 2 for app 6796287377. Marketing evidence, not a live app test. E3.
Original Apple-hosted promotion 2 for app 6796287377. Marketing evidence, not a live app test. E3.
Original Apple-hosted promotion 3 for app 6796287377. Marketing evidence, not a live app test. E3.
Original Apple-hosted promotion 3 for app 6796287377. Marketing evidence, not a live app test. E3.
Original Apple-hosted promotion 4 for app 6796287377. Marketing evidence, not a live app test. E3.
Original Apple-hosted promotion 4 for app 6796287377. Marketing evidence, not a live app test. E3.
Original Apple-hosted promotion 5 for app 6796287377. Marketing evidence, not a live app test. E3.
Original Apple-hosted promotion 5 for app 6796287377. Marketing evidence, not a live app test. E3.
Original Apple-hosted promotion 6 for app 6796287377. Marketing evidence, not a live app test. E3.
Original Apple-hosted promotion 6 for app 6796287377. Marketing evidence, not a live app test. E3.
Original Apple-hosted promotional image 2 for app 6801166041. Marketing evidence, not a runtime test. E19.
Original Apple-hosted promotional image 2 for app 6801166041. Marketing evidence, not a runtime test. E19.
Original Apple-hosted promotional image 3 for app 6801166041. Marketing evidence, not a runtime test. E19.
Original Apple-hosted promotional image 3 for app 6801166041. Marketing evidence, not a runtime test. E19.
Original Apple-hosted promotional image 4 for app 6801166041. Marketing evidence, not a runtime test. E19.
Original Apple-hosted promotional image 4 for app 6801166041. Marketing evidence, not a runtime test. E19.
Original Apple-hosted promotional image 5 for app 6801166041. Marketing evidence, not a runtime test. E19.
Original Apple-hosted promotional image 5 for app 6801166041. Marketing evidence, not a runtime test. E19.
Original Apple-hosted promotion 2 for app 6825284960. Marketing evidence, not a live app test. E2.
Original Apple-hosted promotion 2 for app 6825284960. Marketing evidence, not a live app test. E2.
Original Apple-hosted promotion 3 for app 6825284960. Marketing evidence, not a live app test. E2.
Original Apple-hosted promotion 3 for app 6825284960. Marketing evidence, not a live app test. E2.
Original Apple-hosted promotion 4 for app 6825284960. Marketing evidence, not a live app test. E2.
Original Apple-hosted promotion 4 for app 6825284960. Marketing evidence, not a live app test. E2.
Original Apple-hosted promotion 5 for app 6825284960. Marketing evidence, not a live app test. E2.
Original Apple-hosted promotion 5 for app 6825284960. Marketing evidence, not a live app test. E2.
Original Apple-hosted promotion 6 for app 6825284960. Marketing evidence, not a live app test. E2.
Original Apple-hosted promotion 6 for app 6825284960. Marketing evidence, not a live app test. E2.
Original Apple-hosted promotion 7 for app 6825284960. Marketing evidence, not a live app test. E2.
Original Apple-hosted promotion 7 for app 6825284960. Marketing evidence, not a live app test. E2.
WHAT YOU NEED TO KNOW

A familiar identity is being used to sell a separate app.

What users recognise

Four Notion-led names, N-based monochrome icons and Notion branding in the original promotions; each app has its own independent seller.

Original Apple listings and artwork.

E2 E3 E4 E19 E20

A concrete privacy failure

Arshad’s listing privacy link opens contact information; its binary policy describes CodeFuse. Mobeen’s linked terms describe Invitation Maker. App Sensor’s documents explicitly choose Pakistan as legal jurisdiction.

Live public pages and static URL references.

E3 E7 E9 E23 E24

What the code actually does

All four supplied builds contain real Notion API and Keychain code. Abait, Arshad and Mobeen have separate AI implementations; App Sensor’s supplied build has no recovered AI service endpoint.

Static inspection of signed binaries; no app executed.

E8 E9 E21 E22

What links were established

15 products are linked within four distinct Apple publisher accounts by exact IDs. No extra common-owner account was established from common SDKs or shared service APIs.

Apple account inventories and retained cross-check results.

E10 E11 E12 E25 E26 E27
WHAT IT COSTS

Four independent subscriptions: compare the yearly cost

Current US listing prices checked 21 November 2026. They pay the independent sellers, not evidence of an official Notion subscription. No checkout was tested; actual in-app offers may differ, particularly where the supplied build differs from listing metadata.

Estimated yearly cost of the listed weekly offers: $155.48–$363.48

The table compares the independent sellers’ displayed weekly offers with their yearly plans. The higher cost alone does not establish a scam. The concern is whether Notion-led names and artwork cause buyers to mistake what they are paying for.

Standard annualisation of displayed prices; actual renewal dates and checkout offers can vary. No revenue or actual customer spending is claimed.

WHO IS BEHIND IT?

The name on the listing.

App name
Four independent Notion-branded task apps
Developer / seller
Muhammad Abait / Waleed Arshad / APP SENSOR LLP / Awais Mobeen
Developer country · App ID 6825284960
Unknown · Seller declares non-trader status. No account-linked registered business country or address was established; names, mail suffixes and Google hosting do not establish it.

German and Irish Apple provider panels checked 21 November 2026; E5.

Developer country · App ID 6796287377
Unknown · Seller declares non-trader status. No account-linked registered business country or address was established; names, mail suffixes and Google hosting do not establish it.

German and Irish Apple provider panels checked 21 November 2026; E5.

Developer country · App ID 6801166041
Unknown · No app-linked business address or registration country established. Terms/EULA declare Pakistani law and courts; that separate legal association is preserved. E23.

DE/IE provider panels checked 21 November 2026; E19/E20.

Developer country · App ID 6787069755
Unknown · No app-linked business address or registration country established. Same-name public profiles are not sufficient to identify this seller.

DE/IE provider panels checked 21 November 2026; E19/E20.

App Store listing ↗
App ID, version and other identifiers
App Store ID
6825284960 / 6796287377 / 6801166041 / 6787069755
Bundle identifier
com.todo.abait / com.task.to.do.list.app / com.appsensor.taskora / com.task.todo.list.ai
Version
Abait binary 1.3 (1.3.1); Arshad 1.4 (5); App Sensor 2.0 (10); Mobeen 2.2 (2.3). App Sensor and Mobeen public listing versions differ from the supplied builds; see build table.
First released
Abait: 1 Nov 2026; Arshad: 5 Aug 2026; App Sensor: 3 Sep 2026; Mobeen: 8 Jul 2026.

Real integration does not make these apps official

All four signed binaries contain Notion API clients. A truthful compatibility reference can be legitimate; third-party Notion tools are not inherently scams. The issue is using Notion-led names and familiar N-based artwork as the product’s own sales identity.

Notion’s published guidance permits accurate compatibility descriptions but says a product should lead with its own name and keep the compatibility phrase secondary. It also prohibits confusing imitation of its logo and identity. The report’s assessment concerns that combined presentation; private permission or a licence was not established.

Arshad and App Sensor explicitly disclaim affiliation with Notion. Those disclosures matter, and Notion offers compatibility badges for integrations. Buyers nevertheless encounter the app’s name and icon before the full description. Assess the overall presentation rather than treating either a disclaimer or a badge as conclusive.

Notion trademark guidelines Notion’s own-brand-first naming and badge guidance Official Notion desktop download

E2/E3/E4/E14/E15/E19/E20. Exact promotional images and Notion’s published naming rules.

Each seller’s own prices

Independent app plans and estimated yearly cost
SellerWeekly / MonthlyYearly / OnceWeekly offer: estimated yearly cost
Muhammad Abait$3.99 / $9.99$34.99 / $59.99$207.48 · about 5.9× yearly plan
Waleed Arshad$6.99 / $11.99$29.99 / $59.99$363.48 · about 12.1× yearly plan
APP SENSOR LLP$2.99 / $19.99$29.99 / $49.99$155.48 · about 5.2× yearly plan
Awais Mobeen$3.99 / $8.99$34.99 / $69.99$207.48 · about 5.9× yearly plan

E2/E3/E19/E20. US App Store listing prices, not completed purchases.

The names and icons as users see them on Apple’s pages

Loaded Apple page captures tie the names and icons to the exact sellers. The four inspected US listings did not have enough ratings or reviews to display an overview; this report does not invent customer-confusion complaints.

Apple page identifying app 6825284960, its Notion-led name, N icon and independent seller.
Current Apple product page for app 6825284960, captured 21 November 2026. Muhammad Abait. E2.
Apple page identifying app 6796287377, its Notion-led name, N icon and independent seller.
Current Apple product page for app 6796287377, captured 21 November 2026. Waleed Arshad. E3.
Loaded Apple product page for app 6801166041, captured 21 November 2026. E19.
Loaded Apple product page for app 6801166041, captured 21 November 2026. E19.
Loaded Apple product page for app 6787069755, captured 21 November 2026. E20.
Loaded Apple product page for app 6787069755, captured 21 November 2026. E20.

E2/E3/E19/E20. Browser captures, 21 November 2026.

Three captured identities, all already using Notion

The supplied dossier documents two icon changes for Abait’s app: N with three dots, then a cube/checklist/pencil, then a framed N with a sync badge. The first observed snapshot was 5 November, four days after Apple’s first-release date. Its title already contained “For Notion”.

This proves changes in marketing identity during monitoring. It does not prove that a harmless, unbranded launch was used to bypass App Review; Apple’s original submission and internal review records are not available.

5 November 2026Before: N with three dots. First captured 5 November 2026, 16:46:01 UTC. Original embedded dossier artwork. E1 page 2.
Before: N with three dots. First captured 5 November 2026, 16:46:01 UTC. Original embedded dossier artwork. E1 page 2.
15 November 2026After first recorded change: cube/checklist/pencil. Captured 15 November 2026, 07:16:10 UTC. Original dossier artwork. E1 page 2.
After first recorded change: cube/checklist/pencil. Captured 15 November 2026, 07:16:10 UTC. Original dossier artwork. E1 page 2.
21 November 2026Current: framed N with sync badge. Source monitoring captured 21 November 2026, 07:12:40 UTC; current Apple artwork retrieved independently the same day. E1/E2.
Current: framed N with sync badge. Source monitoring captured 21 November 2026, 07:12:40 UTC; current Apple artwork retrieved independently the same day. E1/E2.

E1 pages 2–4. Snapshot capture times are UTC, distinct from the app’s version-release dates.

The dated source pages behind the icon sequence

Source dossier page 2: first/current comparison and first dated icon update. E1.
Source dossier page 2: first/current comparison and first dated icon update. E1.
Source dossier page 3: second dated icon update and recorded evidence references. E1.
Source dossier page 3: second dated icon update and recorded evidence references. E1.

Complete supplied monitoring dossier; these are source-page captures, not reconstructed App Store screenshots. E1.

A contact page and a policy for CodeFuse

Arshad’s App Store “Privacy Policy” link currently opens a Google Sites support page containing only contact information. It does not explain what this Notion app collects, how long data is retained or how it is deleted.

The signed binary contains a different privacy URL. That page opens successfully, but describes CodeFuse: prompts, code snippets and JSON outputs. It does not give a meaningful app-specific explanation of Notion tokens, task databases, calendars and task-assistant data. Both pages use the same public support contact, connecting the documents to this seller’s product trail.

Abait’s linked policy is also hosted on Google Sites. It is a broad iOS/Android policy covering identifiers, advertising, camera/facial features and AI processing. It does mention AI; the deficiency is that it leaves the data handling of this Mac workspace unclear. Free hosting alone is not evidence of fraud.

The actual destination of Arshad’s App Store privacy link: Contact Us. Browser capture, 21 November 2026. E7.
The actual destination of Arshad’s App Store privacy link: Contact Us. Browser capture, 21 November 2026. E7.
Different privacy URL recovered from Arshad’s signed binary: a CodeFuse policy describing code and JSON processing. Browser capture, 21 November 2026. E7/E9.
Different privacy URL recovered from Arshad’s signed binary: a CodeFuse policy describing code and JSON processing. Browser capture, 21 November 2026. E7/E9.
Static code evidence: listing-support and separate privacy URL literals in Arshad’s binary. The URLs were opened as public pages; no app was executed. E9.
Static code evidence: listing-support and separate privacy URL literals in Arshad’s binary. The URLs were opened as public pages; no app was executed. E9.
Open listing privacy destination Open binary-linked CodeFuse policy Open Abait’s all-app privacy policy

E6/E7/E8/E9. Web pages captured 21 November 2026. Policy language about possible collection is not proof that every listed feature collects data.

Where the code is designed to send information

A Notion token is a key that lets an app access the content permitted by that key. All four supplied builds contain native Notion API clients and Keychain credential code. Manual integration tokens are supported by Notion; OAuth is another option, not a mandatory legitimacy test.

Abait’s app assembles an AI context describing projects, tasks, notes and meeting transcriptions. Its code constructs a JSON POST and a Google-hosted chatGPT function URL belonging to its own Firebase project. That is a separate processing route from Notion. Static inspection establishes the implemented data path; no real workspace, packet capture or server retention was tested.

Arshad’s app contains a direct OpenAI chat-completions client and an AI consent overlay. It also contains a routine for loading an AI key from a cloud configuration document, including an error message recommending publicly readable rules. This is a security design warning, not a demonstrated live credential leak: the document and live rules were not queried, and no recovered credential was used.

Mobeen’s build contains Notion sync, iCloud sync and a direct OpenAI client for meeting-transcript actions. App Sensor’s supplied build contains local task storage and two-way Notion sync; no OpenAI endpoint, AI relay or Firebase configuration was recovered from that build. The broad App Sensor website discusses AI across its products, which does not establish hidden AI processing in this particular app.

Both store pages say Data Not Collected. Sending information off-device does not automatically contradict that label: Apple distinguishes real-time request processing from longer retention. The backends’ actual retention and logging need verification. The poor or wrong-product privacy explanations are established independently of that unanswered question.

Implemented Notion and AI paths in the supplied builds. Dashed arrows mean static code paths, not network requests observed during this investigation. E8/E9.
Implemented Notion and AI paths in the supplied builds. Dashed arrows mean static code paths, not network requests observed during this investigation. E8/E9.
Abait static-code excerpts: workspace-context text, JSON POST construction and separate Google-hosted AI endpoint. The excerpts are recovered from the executable, not original Swift source or live traffic. E8.
Abait static-code excerpts: workspace-context text, JSON POST construction and separate Google-hosted AI endpoint. The excerpts are recovered from the executable, not original Swift source or live traffic. E8.
Arshad static-code excerpts: direct OpenAI endpoint, cloud-key-loading routine, error text about public reads, and AI consent wording. Credential location is partly withheld; no secret is shown or accessed. E9.
Arshad static-code excerpts: direct OpenAI endpoint, cloud-key-loading routine, error text about public reads, and AI consent wording. Credential location is partly withheld; no secret is shown or accessed. E9.
New signed builds: real Notion routes and Keychain storage, Mobeen’s meeting-notes AI endpoint, and the App Sensor listing/build version difference. Static evidence, not live traffic. E21/E22.
New signed builds: real Notion routes and Keychain storage, Mobeen’s meeting-notes AI endpoint, and the App Sensor listing/build version difference. Static evidence, not live traffic. E21/E22.
Notion’s supported authentication methods Apple’s definition of data collection

E8/E9/E21/E22: static code, not runtime traffic. E16/E17: official Notion and Apple documentation. Live credential stores and private backend data were not queried.

The two added apps: real sync, different disclosure problems

App Sensor’s Todo & Tasks for Notion contains a substantial native Notion client and two-way sync code. It stores the integration token in Keychain and its interface explains how to share pages with the connection. Its clipboard N differs from Notion’s serif cube icon; the concern is the combined Notion-led naming and marketing, not a claim that the app has no functionality.

Mobeen’s Task & Todo for Notion also implements Notion access and Keychain storage, with optional iCloud sync and an AI path for meeting notes. Its linked privacy policy names Firebase Analytics/Crashlytics and discusses uploaded facial images. Its terms repeatedly name Invitation Maker and public card galleries. That is a concrete wrong-product document problem for a task, workspace and meeting app.

Mobeen’s binary includes Crashlytics and Firebase Sessions components. Their actual collection and runtime settings were not tested, so the report does not treat SDK presence as a completed transmission. The seller’s own data-collection language deserves reconciliation with its Data Not Collected label.

Mobeen’s linked Terms of Use repeatedly name Invitation Maker. Loaded public document capture, 21 November 2026. E24.
Mobeen’s linked Terms of Use repeatedly name Invitation Maker. Loaded public document capture, 21 November 2026. E24.
Mobeen’s privacy policy Mobeen’s Invitation Maker terms App Sensor privacy policy

E19–E24. All code findings refer to the exact signed supplied builds.

Pakistan: an explicit legal declaration for App Sensor

App Sensor’s own linked Terms and EULA both select Pakistani law and Pakistani courts. That is a direct, app-linked Pakistan association, rather than a guess from a name. It establishes the developer’s declared legal jurisdiction; it does not identify a registered office, company registration number, owner or nationality.

All four inspected German and Irish provider panels show non-trader declarations without a business address. The other three sellers’ names and support pages did not produce a verified seller-linked Pakistan location. Similar-name professional profiles were excluded where no contact, product or technical identifier tied them to the Apple account.

The extra scans found the build-user name macgenics in Mobeen’s embedded library build paths. No public company or account match was established from that name, so it was not converted into a country or ownership claim.

The deeper check also followed the other products on the three individual accounts. Mobeen’s GPS Camera website and older named support form do not disclose a business country. The public domain-registration entry for the separate Tasker support domain identifies a registrar, not this seller. None of these sources supplies the missing identity link needed to attribute a same-name professional profile to the Apple account.

App Sensor’s linked Terms: section 27 selects Pakistani law and courts. This is a legal-jurisdiction declaration, not a verified office address. Browser capture, 21 November 2026. E23.
App Sensor’s linked Terms: section 27 selects Pakistani law and courts. This is a legal-jurisdiction declaration, not a verified office address. Browser capture, 21 November 2026. E23.
App Sensor’s EULA separately selects Pakistani law and competent Pakistani courts. Browser capture, 21 November 2026. E23.
App Sensor’s EULA separately selects Pakistani law and competent Pakistani courts. Browser capture, 21 November 2026. E23.
App Sensor Terms · governing law App Sensor EULA · governing law

E5/E18/E19/E20/E23/E27. Business-country fields remain Unknown; the explicit App Sensor legal-jurisdiction association is recorded separately. E28: extended individual-publisher identity and related-product support checks.

Exact builds, different teams and documented cross-checks

All four supplied apps are native Swift applications with valid Apple signatures. Their signing teams, bundle identifiers and own service configurations differ. A valid signature identifies the signing team; it does not endorse the marketing.

The expanded cross-check covers 28 retained analyses, including these four. A repeated Google logging string was traced to Firebase SDK context and excluded from ownership evidence. Shared Notion/OpenAI endpoints and common framework code likewise do not establish one operator.

App Sensor’s supplied build is 2.0 (10), while its retrieved US listing says 1.0.4. Mobeen’s supplied build is 2.2 (2.3), while its listing says 2.0. These differences may reflect distribution or listing timing; results are tied to the supplied builds and are not a version-mismatch fraud finding.

Apple listing of Uniqly: Writing Assistant naming Muhammad Abait and showing preorder status.
Apple companion listing: Uniqly, Muhammad Abait, expected 30 November 2026. Browser capture 21 November 2026. E10.
Apple listing of AI Chatbot Assistant for You naming Waleed Arshad.
Apple companion listing: AI Chatbot Assistant for You, Waleed Arshad. Its description still calls the app CodeFuse. Browser capture 21 November 2026. E11.
Exact Store IDs and signed builds; listing versions are separate observations
Publisher / app IDSigned buildApple team / bundleRetrieved listing version
Muhammad Abait · 68252849601.3 (1.3.1)728PDN55H2 / com.todo.abait1.3
Waleed Arshad · 67962873771.4 (5)65KYFAYNW2 / com.task.to.do.list.app1.4
APP SENSOR LLP · 68011660412.0 (10)A2NH9H6XFK / com.appsensor.taskora1.0.4
Awais Mobeen · 67870697552.2 (2.3)52CLWC5BG9 / com.task.todo.list.ai2.0
Uniqly: Writing Assistant · preorder AI Chatbot Assistant for You · same Arshad account

E8/E9/E12/E18/E21/E22/E27. Retained original analysis and verified indicator supplements; no apps launched.

Do the four binaries connect the sellers?

Every pair was compared using exact ARM64 function bytes, packaged-file hashes, asset-catalog digests, readable strings and recovered short Swift strings. The question was whether the apps share their own code, artwork or service accounts—not simply the libraries available to every Mac developer.

The identical packaged files are standard SDK privacy manifests or the generic Mac application marker. No matching image rendition was found across the four catalogs. Their shared AppIcon multi-size catalog descriptor lists standard icon sizes; it is not the icon’s pixels. Shared longer text consists of framework messages and Apple certificate wording.

Small identical functions remain in all pairs. The largest inspected matches perform generic number parsing or low-level atomic state operations, without product-specific names or a shared service configuration. These matches are insufficient to attribute a shared app codebase or owner. The cloud projects recovered for Abait, Arshad and Mobeen are different; App Sensor’s supplied build has no recovered Firebase configuration.

The confirmed links are within each Apple account, as shown above. This comparison did not establish an additional account controlled by the same person. Shared visual marketing can justify a branding review without inventing an ownership connection.

Exact machine-code matches requiring provenance; these are not ownership links
Compared publishersMatching function byte rangesMatching app-specific image renditions
Abait / Arshad120
Abait / App Sensor100
Abait / Mobeen140
Arshad / App Sensor130
Arshad / Mobeen170
App Sensor / Mobeen170

E8/E9/E21/E22/E27. Six pairwise comparisons; ARM64 function threshold of 96 bytes. Retained exact hashes, addresses, catalog records and exclusions remain in the private analysis archive.

The complete returned account inventories

These are the products returned by US publisher lookups on 21 November 2026. “Related” means the exact same Apple account here; it is not an accusation against every listed product. Availability can change, and this inventory is not a historical list of everything a seller has ever released.

15 products across four accounts
App / Apple app IDPublisher / Apple developer IDRole in this investigation
Todo List:Workspace For Notion · 6825284960Muhammad Abait · 6825284962primary
Todo List & App for Notion · 6796287377Waleed Arshad · 6776619521primary
Uniqly: Writing Assistant · 6834275899Muhammad Abait · 6825284962related · preorder expected 30 Nov 2026
AI Chatbot Assistant for You · 6776619519Waleed Arshad · 6776619521related
EveryDollars: Budget Planner · 6793542122APP SENSOR LLP · 6790821136related
Todo & Tasks for Notion · 6801166041APP SENSOR LLP · 6790821136primary
Cycle Ahead - Period tracker · 6795199687APP SENSOR LLP · 6790821136related
FormAtlas: Printable Forms · 6792773824APP SENSOR LLP · 6790821136related
AI Meeting Printer App · 6790821134APP SENSOR LLP · 6790821136related
Design Studio For Crafting · 6756431160Awais Mobeen · 1793533465related
Task & Todo for Notion · 6787069755Awais Mobeen · 1793533465primary
GPS Camera Timestamp Photo · 6748852975Awais Mobeen · 1793533465related
AI Photo Editor - Face Retouch · 6751181860Awais Mobeen · 1793533465related
Baby Collage AI Photo Frames · 6808979368Awais Mobeen · 1793533465related
FormsDesk · 6812986791Awais Mobeen · 1793533465related

E10/E11/E25/E26.

Original icons for the account inventories

Show the 15 original portfolio icons
Original Apple-hosted icon for Todo List:Workspace For Notion, Muhammad Abait. Same-account catalog context. E10/E11/E25/E26.
Original Apple-hosted icon for Todo List:Workspace For Notion, Muhammad Abait. Same-account catalog context. E10/E11/E25/E26.
Original Apple-hosted icon for Todo List & App for Notion, Waleed Arshad. Same-account catalog context. E10/E11/E25/E26.
Original Apple-hosted icon for Todo List & App for Notion, Waleed Arshad. Same-account catalog context. E10/E11/E25/E26.
Original Apple-hosted icon for Uniqly: Writing Assistant, Muhammad Abait. Same-account catalog context. E10/E11/E25/E26.
Original Apple-hosted icon for Uniqly: Writing Assistant, Muhammad Abait. Same-account catalog context. E10/E11/E25/E26.
Original Apple-hosted icon for AI Chatbot Assistant for You, Waleed Arshad. Same-account catalog context. E10/E11/E25/E26.
Original Apple-hosted icon for AI Chatbot Assistant for You, Waleed Arshad. Same-account catalog context. E10/E11/E25/E26.
Original Apple-hosted icon for EveryDollars:  Budget Planner, APP SENSOR LLP. Same-account catalog context. E10/E11/E25/E26.
Original Apple-hosted icon for EveryDollars: Budget Planner, APP SENSOR LLP. Same-account catalog context. E10/E11/E25/E26.
Original Apple-hosted icon for Todo & Tasks for Notion, APP SENSOR LLP. Same-account catalog context. E10/E11/E25/E26.
Original Apple-hosted icon for Todo & Tasks for Notion, APP SENSOR LLP. Same-account catalog context. E10/E11/E25/E26.
Original Apple-hosted icon for Cycle Ahead - Period tracker, APP SENSOR LLP. Same-account catalog context. E10/E11/E25/E26.
Original Apple-hosted icon for Cycle Ahead - Period tracker, APP SENSOR LLP. Same-account catalog context. E10/E11/E25/E26.
Original Apple-hosted icon for FormAtlas: Printable Forms, APP SENSOR LLP. Same-account catalog context. E10/E11/E25/E26.
Original Apple-hosted icon for FormAtlas: Printable Forms, APP SENSOR LLP. Same-account catalog context. E10/E11/E25/E26.
Original Apple-hosted icon for AI Meeting Printer App, APP SENSOR LLP. Same-account catalog context. E10/E11/E25/E26.
Original Apple-hosted icon for AI Meeting Printer App, APP SENSOR LLP. Same-account catalog context. E10/E11/E25/E26.
Original Apple-hosted icon for Design Studio For Crafting, Awais Mobeen. Same-account catalog context. E10/E11/E25/E26.
Original Apple-hosted icon for Design Studio For Crafting, Awais Mobeen. Same-account catalog context. E10/E11/E25/E26.
Original Apple-hosted icon for Task & Todo for Notion, Awais Mobeen. Same-account catalog context. E10/E11/E25/E26.
Original Apple-hosted icon for Task & Todo for Notion, Awais Mobeen. Same-account catalog context. E10/E11/E25/E26.
Original Apple-hosted icon for GPS Camera Timestamp Photo, Awais Mobeen. Same-account catalog context. E10/E11/E25/E26.
Original Apple-hosted icon for GPS Camera Timestamp Photo, Awais Mobeen. Same-account catalog context. E10/E11/E25/E26.
Original Apple-hosted icon for AI Photo Editor - Face Retouch, Awais Mobeen. Same-account catalog context. E10/E11/E25/E26.
Original Apple-hosted icon for AI Photo Editor - Face Retouch, Awais Mobeen. Same-account catalog context. E10/E11/E25/E26.
Original Apple-hosted icon for Baby Collage AI Photo Frames, Awais Mobeen. Same-account catalog context. E10/E11/E25/E26.
Original Apple-hosted icon for Baby Collage AI Photo Frames, Awais Mobeen. Same-account catalog context. E10/E11/E25/E26.
Original Apple-hosted icon for FormsDesk, Awais Mobeen. Same-account catalog context. E10/E11/E25/E26.
Original Apple-hosted icon for FormsDesk, Awais Mobeen. Same-account catalog context. E10/E11/E25/E26.

Original Apple-hosted artwork, retrieved 21 November 2026. E10/E11/E25/E26.

What Apple should examine

Compare all four store identities with Notion’s original artwork and naming rules. Require the sellers to establish rights to the Notion-led names and look, and present their independent identity clearly before purchase.

Replace the contact-only privacy link and wrong-product policy with accurate explanations for each Mac app, including Notion access, AI destinations, retention and deletion. Verify consent in the actual released builds and review the client-side AI-key distribution design. The attached code excerpts, signatures and dated source pages make these checks reproducible.

Editorial request based on E1–E17; no Apple enforcement outcome is claimed.

THE FULL RECORD

What else changed?

The supplied monitoring dossier records three snapshots of app 6825284960. Both recorded updates changed its icon. The first captured name already said For Notion; these captures do not establish a brand-neutral launch or an App Review bypass.

Compare all 2 recorded changes
Icon Brand resemblance persists; source dossier page 2.
BEFORE

Large N with three dots; version 1.1.

AFTER

Black-and-white cube with checklist and pencil; version 1.2.

2026-11-15 07:16:10 UTC; supplied monitoring dossier E1.

Icon Returns to prominent N identity; source dossier page 3.
BEFORE

Cube with checklist and pencil; version 1.2.

AFTER

Framed N with circular sync badge; version 1.3.

2026-11-21 07:12:40 UTC; supplied monitoring dossier E1.

View the dates and timeline
  1. Mobeen first release

    Apple exact-ID lookup for app 6787069755; no launch-era icon verified. E20.

  2. Arshad app first released

    Apple exact-ID lookup, app 6796287377. E3.

  3. Arshad version 1.4 released

    Current signed supplied build is 1.4 (5). E3/E9.

  4. App Sensor first release

    Apple exact-ID lookup for app 6801166041; no launch-era icon verified. E19.

  5. Abait app first released

    Apple exact-ID lookup, app 6825284960. No launch-day icon recovered. E2.

  6. First monitored Abait snapshot

    16:46:01 UTC: already named For Notion; N icon with three dots. E1.

  7. First captured icon update

    07:16:10 UTC: cube/checklist icon, version 1.2. E1.

  8. Second captured icon update and investigation

    07:12:40 UTC: framed N with sync badge, version 1.3. Source dossier and current binary checked. E1/E2/E8.

CHECK THE SOURCES

The records behind this report.

Full four-app investigation: the supplied ten-page Abait monitoring dossier, current original Apple artwork and store/legal pages for four sellers, full current account inventories, and static analysis of four supplied Case 11 archives. No app was launched, workspace connected, purchase made or private cloud credential queried. Code paths are not runtime observations. The complete supplied source PDF is appended. Business country and declared legal jurisdiction are distinguished.

Open source files, archive links and checksums

E1 / Complete supplied ten-page monitoring dossier

Generated 21 November 2026, 13:15:35 UTC. All ten pages read and rendered; icon sequence pages 2–4, US/IE disclosures pages 5–6, original promotions page 8. Source hash independently calculated.

SHA-256: 5f137bfbf1471e78904b22a5299497fb4a50f188de0fcd6b9fb00e74a20750f5

E2 / Abait current Apple listing and original artwork

US listing, exact-ID lookup and seven original promotional images, retrieved 21 November 2026. App 6825284960; developer 6825284962.

Open source ↗

E3 / Arshad current Apple listing and original artwork

US listing, exact-ID lookup, six original promotional images, affiliation disclaimer and listed purchases, retrieved 21 November 2026. App 6796287377; developer 6776619521.

Open source ↗

E4 / Official Notion brand reference

Notion Labs, Incorporated; original Apple-hosted mobile icon, app 1232780281, retrieved 21 November 2026.

Open source ↗

E5 / German and Irish provider disclosures

Both apps identify as non-traders in inspected EU panels. No registered business address/country is shown. Both DE and IE copies retained privately; checked 21 November 2026.

Open source ↗

E6 / Abait all-app privacy and terms pages

Google Sites documents checked 21 November 2026; broad mobile-app policy includes AI processing and optional data categories. Terms linked from app description.

Open source ↗

E7 / Arshad listing privacy destination

Current contact-only page. Separate binary-linked policy at sites.google.com/view/privacy-policy-wale/home describes CodeFuse. Both public pages retrieved and captured 21 November 2026.

Open source ↗

E8 / Abait supplied signed binary

Read-only static inspection, 21 November 2026. Version 1.3 (1.3.1), bundle com.todo.abait, Apple team 728PDN55H2. Signature validates. No app executed. Executable SHA-256 297c81164f6393718133bf5796bfeb617b784be901f4052f18b00bc3d0484eb1. Code-address excerpts and private retained indicator record distinguish static presence from runtime use.

SHA-256: 7e7a03e0d24607ffd524c838f543bb3f106a474879889550c6cfabb4aa3e3540

E9 / Arshad supplied signed binary

Read-only static inspection, 21 November 2026. Version 1.4 (5), bundle com.task.to.do.list.app, Apple team 65KYFAYNW2. Signature validates. No app executed. Executable SHA-256 a4f5b1619adc7f605bc73e859a8b70c1e5e177b5c2ccbfdd40ad0307d5d8ed92. Code-address excerpts and private retained indicator record distinguish static presence from runtime use.

SHA-256: add825d52718733352a95357bed1d6577cd7d19b73ca0b3ffa02e37b1b0804f9

E10 / Muhammad Abait account inventory

Apple lookup returns apps 6825284960 and 6834275899. Uniqly is a preorder expected 30 November 2026. Exact publisher ID and current Apple preorder page checked 21 November 2026.

Open source ↗

E11 / Waleed Arshad account inventory

Apple lookup returns apps 6796287377 and 6776619519. Companion’s exact bundle is com.ai.codefuse. Checked 21 November 2026.

Open source ↗

E12 / Cross-case static indicator comparison

Private comparison of both supplied signed builds with 24 other indexed analyses, 21 November 2026. No exact account-specific signing-team/project/contact/legal-page match found. Common SDK references excluded.

E13 / Apple App Review Guidelines

Current rules checked 21 November 2026; assessment focuses on accurate metadata, copycats/IP, privacy and security.

Open source ↗

E14 / Notion Trademark Usage Guidelines

Official guidance permits truthful compatibility references and restricts using Notion’s name as an app identity or confusing imitation. Checked 21 November 2026.

Open source ↗

E15 / Notion brand naming and integration badge guidance

Official own-brand-first naming and secondary compatibility/badge guidance, checked 21 November 2026.

Open source ↗

E16 / Notion API authorisation documentation

Official documentation covers personal access tokens, internal integration tokens and OAuth. Checked 21 November 2026.

Open source ↗

E17 / Apple privacy-label definitions

Real-time processing distinguished from longer-access collection. Checked 21 November 2026.

Open source ↗

E18 / Extended account and country investigation

21 November 2026: account-specific indicators compared across 26 retained analyses (the two supplied builds plus 24 others), 304 private monitoring records, public seller/contact searches, publisher history queries and public policy navigation. All 62 non-receipt application files were scanned for geographic/source-user traces. No additional directly associated Apple account or seller-linked Pakistan address/profile was established. Same-name people and generic Google Sites/SDK references excluded. Private research records retained.

E19 / App Sensor — current Apple pages and original artwork

US exact-ID lookup and original five Mac promotions; German/Irish non-trader panels without registered address, checked 21 November 2026.

Open source ↗

E20 / Awais Mobeen — current Apple pages and original artwork

US exact-ID lookup and original four Mac promotions; German/Irish non-trader panels without registered address, checked 21 November 2026.

Open source ↗

E21 / Added signed binary: Todo Task.app

Static read-only inspection, 21 November 2026. Bundle com.appsensor.taskora, version 2.0 (10), team A2NH9H6XFK. Signature validates. Executable SHA-256 68e5b2eaaa573bf3358c96104b036b36cd6ffc0887becb57562e05ca9fa37a34. This supplied build differs from the retrieved listing version; no app executed.

SHA-256: 302ee4a6e9ef90f6568693b0525d3933514552c2257cdf6f2f49c0ac7e1beb21

E22 / Added signed binary: Task & Todo.app

Static read-only inspection, 21 November 2026. Bundle com.task.todo.list.ai, version 2.2 (2.3), team 52CLWC5BG9. Signature validates. Executable SHA-256 8d8a04ae2cc5af67af027c119f251144afd49e47146b2b337943da59025917af. This supplied build differs from the retrieved listing version; no app executed.

SHA-256: 200782cbc9a9f6c69cfb71494584fde456cb73f4792c7d01d324b4d335191d90

E23 / App Sensor developer-linked Terms and EULA

Both documents explicitly select Pakistani law and courts. Terms section 27; separate EULA at sites.google.com/view/appsensor/eula. These are declared legal-jurisdiction statements, not verified company-registration or ownership records. Captured 21 November 2026.

Open source ↗

E24 / Mobeen developer-linked policy and Invitation Maker terms

Privacy page names Firebase Analytics/Crashlytics and image processing; terms describe Invitation Maker/card galleries. Both use the same public support contact. Documents linked in the listing and signed binary, checked 21 November 2026.

Open source ↗

E25 / App Sensor complete current US account lookup

Apple developer 6790821136 returns five products. Exact IDs, original icons and bundle IDs retained; checked 21 November 2026.

Open source ↗

E26 / Awais Mobeen complete current US account lookup

Apple developer 1793533465 returns six products. Exact IDs, original icons and bundle IDs retained; checked 21 November 2026.

Open source ↗

E27 / Expanded static, contact and geographic cross-check

28 retained analyses (four investigated here plus 24 other builds); original raw strings/configuration and SDK provenance reviewed. Common Google logging marker traced to SDK context and excluded; common service endpoints excluded. All non-receipt paths scanned with ASCII, UTF-16 and recovered Swift small-string methods. Build-user macgenics found only in Mobeen; no public attributable company/account match established. No private backend or credential document was accessed. Six pairwise ARM64 function/hash, packaged-file, asset-catalog and string comparisons completed. No shared application-specific image rendition or attributable common app backend established; standard multi-size icon descriptors, SDK manifests, generic integer/atomic helpers and certificate text excluded from ownership evidence.

E28 / Extended individual-publisher identity and related-product support checks

Original account catalogs, exact public support contacts, GPS Camera website and older named app help desk, plus public registry and profile-link checks on 21 November 2026. No seller-linked registered office recovered for the three individual publishers. Same-name professional profiles, generic host locations and sample GPS coordinates excluded from country attribution.

Open source ↗