App Scam DBBY ALEX KLEBER
← ALL INVESTIGATIONS
Misleading-name and privacy warning · Authentication utilities

Authy names, different publishers. Who are you trusting?

Two more developer accounts flagged for suspected scams and misleading brand impersonation: Appios Bilisim and MAN LI / Shield Apps. Two reviewers say they installed Authly while searching for Twilio’s Authy; the separate Shield Apps publisher puts Authy in its title and Duo in its English subtitle. Its 15-app catalog also contains Google-coloured icons and prominent Google/Dropbox marketing. These are separate publisher groups; the documented connections and branding assessments are distinguished from proven fraud or common ownership.

VISUAL EVIDENCE

Authly, the real Authy, and a separate app named with Authy

Original Apple icons: Authly by Appios; official Twilio Authy by Authy Inc.; and the separate Shield Apps authenticator by 满 李. Their icons differ. The name and publisher mismatch is the core authentication-app warning; the wider Shield Apps catalog is compared below.

Current app · AppiosAuthly /6476198484 · Appios Bilisim. Current original Apple artwork. E5.
Authly /6476198484 · Appios Bilisim. Current original Apple artwork. E5.
Official reference · Authy Inc.Twilio Authy /494168017 · Authy Inc. Official original Apple artwork. E6/E7.
Twilio Authy /494168017 · Authy Inc. Official original Apple artwork. E6/E7.
Separate app · Shield AppsBlue shield icon of the separate Shield Apps authenticator using Authy in its title.
Authenticator App - Authy, 2FA / 6444312209. Original Apple iPhone icon; separate seller 满 李. E40/E44.
Download full dossier · PDF ↓
LOOK FOR YOURSELF

The screenshots tell the story.

The second publisher’s live Mac page shows the exact Authy/Duo title combination. The supplied Authly review capture documents a different app’s real name-confusion complaints; those complaints are not attributed to Shield Apps. The expandable gallery preserves original Apple promotional images and the supplied native Authly capture.

See all 12 additional screenshots
Original Authly iPhone promotion1, retrieved from Apple’s exact-ID software record on 13 November2026. E5.
Original Authly iPhone promotion1, retrieved from Apple’s exact-ID software record on 13 November2026. E5.
Original native US Apple page capture extracted from supplied dossier page9, 13 November2026 at09: 25: 02 UTC. It includes both favourable and critical review cards.
Original native US Apple page capture extracted from supplied dossier page9, 13 November2026 at09: 25: 02 UTC. It includes both favourable and critical review cards.
Original Authly iPhone promotion2, retrieved from Apple’s exact-ID software record on 13 November2026. E5.
Original Authly iPhone promotion2, retrieved from Apple’s exact-ID software record on 13 November2026. E5.
Original Authly iPhone promotion3, retrieved from Apple’s exact-ID software record on 13 November2026. E5.
Original Authly iPhone promotion3, retrieved from Apple’s exact-ID software record on 13 November2026. E5.
Original Authly iPhone promotion4, retrieved from Apple’s exact-ID software record on 13 November2026. E5.
Original Authly iPhone promotion4, retrieved from Apple’s exact-ID software record on 13 November2026. E5.
Original Authly iPhone promotion5, retrieved from Apple’s exact-ID software record on 13 November2026. E5.
Original Authly iPhone promotion5, retrieved from Apple’s exact-ID software record on 13 November2026. E5.
Original Authly iPhone promotion6, retrieved from Apple’s exact-ID software record on 13 November2026. E5.
Original Authly iPhone promotion6, retrieved from Apple’s exact-ID software record on 13 November2026. E5.
Original Authly iPhone promotion7, retrieved from Apple’s exact-ID software record on 13 November2026. E5.
Original Authly iPhone promotion7, retrieved from Apple’s exact-ID software record on 13 November2026. E5.
Original Authly iPad promotion1, retrieved from Apple’s exact-ID software record on 13 November2026. E5.
Original Authly iPad promotion1, retrieved from Apple’s exact-ID software record on 13 November2026. E5.
Original Authly iPad promotion2, retrieved from Apple’s exact-ID software record on 13 November2026. E5.
Original Authly iPad promotion2, retrieved from Apple’s exact-ID software record on 13 November2026. E5.
Original Authly iPad promotion3, retrieved from Apple’s exact-ID software record on 13 November2026. E5.
Original Authly iPad promotion3, retrieved from Apple’s exact-ID software record on 13 November2026. E5.
Original Authly iPad promotion4, retrieved from Apple’s exact-ID software record on 13 November2026. E5.
Original Authly iPad promotion4, retrieved from Apple’s exact-ID software record on 13 November2026. E5.
WHAT YOU NEED TO KNOW

A trusted name can lead to a different publisher.

A different publisher puts Authy and Duo in its identity.

Authenticator App - Authy, 2FA uses the English subtitle Duo Authy Authenticator App. Apple names 满 李 / MAN LI, and the working legal pages identify LI MAN. Neither official Authy Inc. nor Duo Security LLC is the listed seller. This prominent brand-keyword combination risks confusing people choosing software to protect login codes.

E40/E41/E46/E47; official references E6/E7 and E55.

E40 E41 E46 E55

People looking for Authy say they installed Authly instead.

Two US reviews dated 5 November 2024 and 24 March 2025 explicitly describe the Authy/Authly name confusion. The March reviewer says no money was paid; the report does not turn these complaints into payment receipts or verified fraud losses.

E1 / E2 / E6 / E7 · Dated source records linked below.

E1 E2 E6 E7

A security app sends its privacy button to a 404.

The current Apple privacy button points to a missing Appios page. Separate links inside the description still open Google Sites policies named Authie, with missing operator fields and a legacy SBA support contact.

E2 / E8 / E9 / E10 / E11 · Dated source records linked below.

E2 E8 E9 E10 E11

The publisher-history trail extends beyond one app.

Current Apple data lists 13 Appios apps. Secondary exact-ID catalogs associate Authly, Gun Identifier and Antique Identifier with the older SBA identity, while Authly’s own linked policy retains the SBA domain. No Apple enforcement-evasion conclusion follows from these records alone.

E5 / E9 / E15 / E19 / E30 / E31 · Dated source records linked below.

E5 E9 E15 E19 E30 E31

The second authenticator has its own identity mismatch.

Auth Authenticator is on the same Appios account. A secondary catalog retains its former Authy Authenticator title, and its current linked policies name ERSIN LTD instead of the current Apple seller.

E5 / E12 / E13 / E14 / E20 · Dated source records linked below.

E5 E12 E13 E14 E20

The second account also markets Google- and Dropbox-related Mac apps.

Apple confirms 15 products on developer1653727587. Gmail, Docs and Photos icons combine red, yellow, green and blue; original Docs/Dropbox promotions use unqualified #1 badges. Google Drive and Dropbox currently use a generic cloud icon, not the official product icons. Review the exact comparisons rather than treating every utility as a proven scam.

E44/E56/E58/E59/E60.

E44 E58 E60
WHAT IT COSTS

Authly’s weekly offer has an estimated yearly cost of $363.48.

Authly6476198484 only. The US, German and Irish listings show separate weekly, monthly and yearly purchase options. These are listed prices, not observed charges. A monthly subscription tile advertises a free trial, but no trial duration was verified in the checked iOS page. Purchase flow and equivalent benefits between plans were not tested.

Weekly versus yearly: about 9.1 times the listed US annual option

At an unchanged weekly rate and without cancellation, the estimated yearly equivalent is $363.48, compared with the separately listed $39.99 yearly plan. In Germany/Ireland it is €415.48 versus €44.99, about 9.2 times. These are renewal-cost estimates, not a claim that a customer paid those totals.

Prices: source dossier pages 1-3 and fresh Apple listings E2-E4. Billing intervals and calendar renewal dates can affect actual yearly charges.

Prices displayed in the saved listing
Purchase optionUnited StatesIreland
Premium Access, 1 Week$6.99 weekly€7.99 weekly
Premium Access, 1 Month$12.99 monthly€14.99 monthly
Premium Access, 1 Year$39.99 yearly€44.99 yearly
WHO IS BEHIND IT?

The name on the listing.

App name
Authly / Authenticator App - Authy, 2FA
Developer / seller
Appios Bilisim / 满 李 (MAN LI, Shield Apps)
Developer country · App ID 6476198484
Turkey · Apple-declared trader business location: Basiskele/Kocaeli; corroborated by the same legal company’s homepage and Google Play disclosure, not nationality.

E1 page2; current German E3 and Irish E4 provider records,13 November2026, DUNS 595951912.

Developer country · App ID 6444312209
Unknown · Apple DE/IE gives a non-trader provider notice without a location. Linked website RDAP declares registrant region Hubei, CN; this is domain-registration geography, not a verified seller business address.

E42/E43/E48.

App Store listing ↗
App ID, version and other identifiers
App Store ID
6476198484 / 6444312209
Version
Authly1.1; Shield authenticator iPhone3.7.5 / Mac3.7.8
First released
31 January 2024 · Apple app release field

Authy in the title. Duo in the subtitle. A different seller.

The added case is Authenticator App - Authy, 2FA, App ID6444312209, bundle com.maxapps.authenticator, on Apple developer1653727587. Its US/Irish English subtitle is Duo Authy Authenticator App. Apple identifies the seller as 满 李; the EU provider panel renders MAN LI, and the linked policies use LI MAN. The copyright and working product site use Shield Apps. These are a documented account/brand association, not the official Authy or Duo publisher.

Placing two established authentication-product names in the searchable title/subtitle makes this more than a buried compatibility reference. App Scam DB’s assessment is misleading brand-keyword presentation: a buyer searching for Authy or Duo can encounter a separately sold authenticator carrying both names. The observed blue shield is visibly different from official Authy’s red icon and Duo’s green icon; no copied-Authy-icon verdict is claimed.

Twilio ended its official Windows/macOS/Linux Authy desktop apps on19March2024. The Shield Apps Mac listing is a separate product, not a verified return of official Authy Desktop. Its current Mac page shows version3.7.8; the iPhone API shows3.7.5. The platform records are kept separate.

The visible US reviews include praise and setup-difficulty complaints. They do not provide an explicit Authy-confusion or proven-payment-loss account comparable to the Authly reviews. Those two earlier complaints remain attributed to Authly alone.

Third-party appShield Apps authenticator: blue shield, different seller. E40/E44.
Shield Apps authenticator: blue shield, different seller. E40/E44.
Official Duo referenceOfficial Duo Mobile /422663827 by Duo Security LLC. Original Apple icon. E55.
Official Duo Mobile /422663827 by Duo Security LLC. Original Apple icon. E55.
Open this app’s Mac listing Official Authy desktop end-of-life notice

E40/E41/E46/E47/E67.

A Google-coloured mail icon, and a broken privacy-button domain.

Quick Access for Gmail + uses diagonal red, yellow, green and blue bands around a white envelope. Official Gmail uses a coloured M envelope mark on white. The palette and Gmail title create a recognisable Google association, while the geometry differs; these are not identical icons.

The description declares an independent app using the Gmail API and denies Google affiliation. The download is currently free and the inspected listing has no in-app-purchase section. It would be inaccurate to describe this specific app as a paid Gmail subscription scam.

Its App Store privacy button points to www.shieldapps.cc/quickaccessforgmail/privacy, which failed name resolution; Google DNS returned NXDOMAIN. The description points to a different, working .top policy. A working alternate page does not make the actual Apple privacy button accessible.

Third-party GmailShield Apps /6757919783: original current Apple icon. E56.
Shield Apps /6757919783: original current Apple icon. E56.
Official referenceOfficial Gmail: original current Apple icon from Google. E49.
Official Gmail: original current Apple icon from Google. E49.
Open the Gmail-named listing

E56/E49. E63/E64; official brand guidance E65.

Google Docs in the promotion, Google colours in the icon.

Quick Access for Google Docs uses the same four-colour diagonal background with a white document/image symbol. Official Google Docs uses a blue document icon. The report shows both originals so readers can see the Google-colour association and the distinct shape.

The first original promotion leads with Google Docs for Mac, includes the official-looking Docs/Sheets/Slides product marks, and adds a #1 Google Docs laurel badge. No chart, territory, category, date or ranking source is supplied for that badge in the inspected listing. That is an unsubstantiated promotional ranking claim, not a ranking independently verified here.

The description also states that the app is independent, built with Google APIs and not affiliated with Google. Listed upgrades are $14.99 annually and $19.99 lifetime. The disclaimer is material, but it does not itself establish permission to adopt the overall brand presentation.

Third-party Google DocsShield Apps /6756507719: original current Apple icon. E58.
Shield Apps /6756507719: original current Apple icon. E58.
Official referenceOfficial Google Docs: original current Apple icon from Google. E51.
Official Google Docs: original current Apple icon from Google. E51.
Open the Google Docs-named listing

E58/E51; official brand guidance E65.

Google Photos branding around an embedded web experience.

Quick Access for Google Photos uses four diagonal Google-coloured bands with a white stacked-photo symbol; official Google Photos has a multicolour pinwheel. The shared palette and product name can suggest the Google ecosystem, but the icons are visibly different.

The policy explicitly describes an embedded photos.google.com website for browsing and Google Photos API uploads for native shortcuts. The listing says it is an independent companion, and current wording distinguishes free web access from paid native tools. This report does not call it a fake API integration or claim those capabilities were tested.

The current listing offers $14.99 yearly or $19.99 lifetime for its Pro tools. The concern is the combined brand-led identity and which publisher users may think they are choosing, not the mere existence of a third-party client.

Third-party Google PhotosShield Apps /6768488342: original current Apple icon. E59.
Shield Apps /6768488342: original current Apple icon. E59.
Official referenceOfficial Google Photos: original current Apple icon from Google. E52.
Official Google Photos: original current Apple icon from Google. E52.
Open the Google Photos-named listing

E59/E52; official brand guidance E65.

The cloud icons differ. The promotions still borrow brand authority.

Quick Access for Dropbox6754376846 and Quick Access for Google Drive6754816629 use generic blue cloud-and-sync icons. These are not the official Dropbox box or Google Drive triangle, and this report does not label them exact icon copies. Their exact Apple artist IDs still confirm membership of the same Shield Apps account.

The Dropbox promotion says Dropbox App for Mac, reproduces the Dropbox mark beside Finder and adds #1 Dropbox App. The inspected listing gives no territory, category, date or source for the ranking badge. App Scam DB flags that combination as a misleading-affiliation and unsubstantiated-ranking risk.

Current Dropbox wording explicitly denies affiliation and states use of the official Dropbox API. Current Drive wording puts its independence disclaimer at the start and explains that payment unlocks the third-party app, adds no Google storage and is not paid to Google. Those clear statements materially distinguish the current Drive presentation from a claim to be the official Google product.

A Dropbox reviewer, BPhnl, complained on24October of errors and unfamiliar files. The developer answered that shared folders in the signed-in account could explain this and advised checking the intended account. This is a user complaint and a published explanation, not a verified cross-account data leak. The page also contains a detailed positive support review; neither is evidence of a fabricated review.

Shield Apps Dropbox clientThird-party Dropbox client: generic cloud/sync icon. E60.
Third-party Dropbox client: generic cloud/sync icon. E60.
Official DropboxOfficial Dropbox /327630330 by Dropbox, Inc. E53.
Official Dropbox /327630330 by Dropbox, Inc. E53.
Shield Apps Drive clientThird-party Drive client: generic cloud/sync icon. E57.
Third-party Drive client: generic cloud/sync icon. E57.
Official Google DriveOfficial Google Drive /507874739. E50.
Official Google Drive /507874739. E50.

E60/E57/E53/E50/E66.

Original promotions: the names, badges and screenshots users see

These are the original Apple-hosted marketing images, not recreated product screenshots. Google Docs and Dropbox show the unqualified #1 badges. The Gmail and Photos images show the app interfaces and the service names; product-logo use inside an integration screenshot is not by itself proof of fraud.

Original Google Docs for Mac promotion with #1 Google Docs badge and Google product marks. E58.
Original Google Docs for Mac promotion with #1 Google Docs badge and Google product marks. E58.
Original Dropbox App for Mac promotion, Dropbox mark and #1 Dropbox App badge. E60.
Original Dropbox App for Mac promotion, Dropbox mark and #1 Dropbox App badge. E60.
Original Quick Access for Gmail promotional interface; distinct third-party app name. E56.
Original Quick Access for Gmail promotional interface; distinct third-party app name. E56.
Original Google Photos client promotion showing the embedded web interface. E59.
Original Google Photos client promotion showing the embedded web interface. E59.

E41/E58/E60/E56/E59.

Who is Shield Apps, and what does the authenticator cost?

The strongest direct connection is the Apple account itself: the 15 current products share developer1653727587. The working shieldapps.top homepage links exact product IDs and repeats the same support mailbox found in Apple responses and Notion policies. The legal pages name LI MAN. No corporate registration number, verified shareholders or additional Apple account under common control was recovered.

The official .top registry record preserves registrant country CN and region hu bei, while name and contact details are redacted. The domain was registered18November2025 through Alibaba Cloud and uses HiChina nameservers. This is a source-backed China/Hubei domain-registration indicator, not nationality inferred from the seller’s name or an Apple-verified trading address. The app-specific business country remains Unknown because the inspected EU provider panels give no address.

Both Germany and Ireland say MAN LI has not identified as a trader. That published status sits alongside paid authenticator upgrades and a professional 15-app product site, creating a concrete commercial-status question for Apple to review. The report does not make a legal determination of the operator’s trader status.

The authenticator lists US annual purchases at $9.99 and $14.99, monthly at $4.99, and lifetime purchases at $29.99 and $39.99. These are distinct listed options, not one verified checkout offer. No weekly purchase is listed in the inspected US table. The earlier Authly $6.99 weekly plan must not be attributed to this app.

The Notion privacy page is readable and names LI MAN; it claims no personal/usage collection and device/iCloud storage, consistent in broad wording with its Apple Data Not Collected label. Its terms leave governing law tied to the unspecified jurisdiction where LI MAN is situated. App traffic, key storage, cryptography and purchase flows were not tested.

Actual loaded Shield Apps homepage and authenticator product card. E45.
Actual loaded Shield Apps homepage and authenticator product card. E45.
Open the Shield Apps product site

E40/E42/E43/E45/E46/E47/E48.

All 15 apps: exact identities and what the review established

Every current catalog product was checked, including its original icon, available promotional images, public listing, privacy link and exact artist ID. The six service-named clients and the authenticator receive the specific branding assessments above. The other tools use generic utility names/icons; their presence on this account does not establish impersonation or fraud.

Dislike Checker for YouTube +6741679691 uses a thumb-down icon rather than YouTube’s play button and explicitly says its estimates come from Return YouTube Dislike, not official YouTube dislike totals. Smart Printer’s subtitle lists printer brands as compatibility claims, with a generic printer icon; no copied manufacturer logo was identified in its inspected first two promotions.

A separate historical lead is AdBlock Pro for Desktop6449941759, attributed by search-indexed secondary catalogs to 满 李 and the Shield Apps mailbox. Current Apple US/DE/IE lookups return no product, and its US page returns404. The original full secondary page could not be retrieved; disappearance does not establish an Apple fraud ban, and the current account remains active.

Current US catalog: developer1653727587. Exact IDs are clickable in the links below.
Product / Apple IDBundle IDObserved presentation
Quick Access for Gmail + / 6757919783com.shieldapps.quickemailGoogle palette + Gmail name; broken .cc privacy button; currently free
Quick Access for Google Drive / 6754816629com.shieldapps.googledriveGeneric cloud icon; strong current independence disclosure
Quick Access for Dropbox / 6754376846com.shieldapps.dropboxyDropbox mark and #1 promotion; generic cloud icon; disclaimer present
Quick Access for Google Docs / 6756507719com.shieldapps.quickdocsGoogle palette + Docs naming; unqualified #1 promotion
Authenticator App - Authy, 2FA / 6444312209com.maxapps.authenticatorAuthy title + Duo subtitle: misleading brand-keyword assessment
QR Code Scanner: QR Reader / 6502285859com.shieldapps.qrscannerGeneric utility branding in the inspected images; no specific impersonation established
File Vault: Safe Photos, Files / 6746962777com.shieldapps.vaultboxGeneric utility branding in the inspected images; no specific impersonation established
Smart Printer App: eSign PDF / 6740662679com.shieldapps.printerGeneric printer icon; HP/Epson/Brother/Canon compatibility subtitle
Copy Text On Screen: OCR / 6476453001com.shield.textsnapperGeneric utility branding in the inspected images; no specific impersonation established
QR Code Generator: QR Maker / 6749896568com.shieldapps.qrgeneratorGeneric utility branding in the inspected images; no specific impersonation established
Quick Access for Google Photos / 6768488342com.shieldapps.quickphotosGoogle palette + Photos naming; independent companion disclosed
Private Photo Vault: Secret / 6752824775com.shieldapps.photovaultGeneric utility branding in the inspected images; no specific impersonation established
Batch PDF OCR: Fast & Accurate / 6752823571com.shieldapps.pdfocrGeneric utility branding in the inspected images; no specific impersonation established
Dislike Checker for YouTube + / 6741679691com.shieldapps.dislikesDifferent thumb-down icon; Return YouTube Dislike data source disclosed
SnapText: OCR, Copy, Translate / 6746952808com.shieldapps.snaptextGeneric utility branding in the inspected images; no specific impersonation established
Quick Access for Gmail + / 6757919783 Quick Access for Google Drive / 6754816629 Quick Access for Dropbox / 6754376846 Quick Access for Google Docs / 6756507719 Authenticator App - Authy, 2FA / 6444312209 QR Code Scanner: QR Reader / 6502285859 File Vault: Safe Photos, Files / 6746962777 Smart Printer App: eSign PDF / 6740662679 Copy Text On Screen: OCR / 6476453001 QR Code Generator: QR Maker / 6749896568 Quick Access for Google Photos / 6768488342 Private Photo Vault: Secret / 6752824775 Batch PDF OCR: Fast & Accurate / 6752823571 Dislike Checker for YouTube + / 6741679691 SnapText: OCR, Copy, Translate / 6746952808

E44; all15 primary product pages retained privately. Legacy lead E69.

Other tools reviewed: original utility icons 1

These are current original Apple icons from the same account. The inspected branding does not establish a particular official app being impersonated. The complete table above records the exact identity of each product.

QR Code Scanner: QR Reader / 6502285859. Original Apple icon. E44.
QR Code Scanner: QR Reader / 6502285859. Original Apple icon. E44.
File Vault: Safe Photos, Files / 6746962777. Original Apple icon. E44.
File Vault: Safe Photos, Files / 6746962777. Original Apple icon. E44.
Smart Printer App: eSign PDF / 6740662679. Original Apple icon. E44.
Smart Printer App: eSign PDF / 6740662679. Original Apple icon. E44.
Copy Text On Screen: OCR / 6476453001. Original Apple icon. E44.
Copy Text On Screen: OCR / 6476453001. Original Apple icon. E44.

E44.

Other tools reviewed: original utility icons 2

These are current original Apple icons from the same account. The inspected branding does not establish a particular official app being impersonated. The complete table above records the exact identity of each product.

QR Code Generator: QR Maker / 6749896568. Original Apple icon. E44.
QR Code Generator: QR Maker / 6749896568. Original Apple icon. E44.
Private Photo Vault: Secret / 6752824775. Original Apple icon. E44.
Private Photo Vault: Secret / 6752824775. Original Apple icon. E44.
Batch PDF OCR: Fast & Accurate / 6752823571. Original Apple icon. E44.
Batch PDF OCR: Fast & Accurate / 6752823571. Original Apple icon. E44.
SnapText: OCR, Copy, Translate / 6746952808. Original Apple icon. E44.
SnapText: OCR, Copy, Translate / 6746952808. Original Apple icon. E44.

E44.

A repeated Authy-name concern does not prove one operator

Authly6476198484 and Authenticator App - Authy, 2FA6444312209 are separate current Apple account identities. The first belongs to Appios developer1796567865; the second to 满 李 developer1653727587. The reviewed support domains, legal-provider names and bundle IDs do not establish a shared owner, transfer, binary reuse or common account controller between them.

The Appios-SBA product history and ERSIN/named-developer leads remain documented in the following sections. They must not be drawn as ownership edges to Shield Apps just because both publishers use Authy-related wording. The direct Shield Apps grouping consists of its own exact account membership, shared support identity and linked product site.

Archive lookup returned four exact-URL captures for the added authenticator, but replay was blocked429. Its Apple release date is6December2022; without readable historical captures this investigation does not invent a generic-launch-to-Authy change or a return after a ban.

Publisher separation and direct identifiers for Apple review
GroupDirect recordConnection established
Appios BilisimApple developer1796567865; Authly6476198484Current account and labelled SBA/ERSIN/developer-attribution trails
Shield Apps / 满 李 / MAN LI / LI MANApple developer1653727587; authenticator644431220915 current products, same site/support/legal identity
Between the two groupsDifferent artist IDs, domains and named operatorsRepeated naming concern; shared control not established

E5/E9/E15/E25/E27; E44/E45/E46/E68.

One extra letter. A different security provider.

Authly inserts an L into Authy. In the same authenticator category, that small spelling change can be easy to miss. Two dated buyers describe exactly that mistake; App Scam DB assesses the naming as misleading in this documented context.

The official reference is Twilio Authy by Authy Inc., app 494168017. Authly is a separate Appios product, app 6476198484. The icons below are visually different: Authly uses a blue shield/lock, while Authy uses its red mark. The evidence supports a name-and-supplier confusion warning, not a claim that Authly copied Authy’s icon.

Authly’s description also lists Authy and Twilio among many purportedly supported services. Naming compatible services is not automatically an affiliation claim. The warning rests on the near-identical product name and the concrete confusion reported by buyers.

The listing offers iPhone/iPad and Apple Watch support, with M1-or-later Mac compatibility also shown by Apple. This is not evidence of a separately verified native Mac edition. E1/E2/E5.

E1/E2/E6/E7/E28.

The reviews describe the exact mix-up

On 24 March 2025, HazeFDC reported searching for Authy, installing Authly and noticing the extra L only afterward. The reviewer also alleged non-working codes and repeated subscription prompts, but explicitly said the app received no payment. Those functionality claims were not reproduced in an independent test.

On 5 November 2024, Mcfly_R likewise contrasted AuthY with AuthLY and objected to the subscription presentation. The reviewer alleged paid search placement; this investigation did not obtain ad-account or ranking-manipulation evidence.

Other reviews praise the app’s widget and import/export features. The checked US listing displays 4.2 stars from 216 ratings. Two selected complaints establish documented user confusion, not the experience of every user or a verified count of financial losses.

Read the reviews on Apple’s US listing

E1 page 7; fresh Apple text E2. Supplied page 9 preserves the original native product-page capture.

Apple’s privacy button is broken; the other policies name Authie

The App Store privacy button opens appios.com.tr/privacy.html, which returned 404 in the supplied analysis and in the independent check. Appios’s working homepage links the same missing route. Its separate legacy contact.html route also returned 404; the homepage still displays a company-contact section.

Inside the app description, different links lead to authie-privacy and authie-terms on Google Sites. The privacy page leaves the opening provider-name slots blank; the terms omit the named rights-holder in their ownership sentence. Both use the legacy sbatech.uk support domain rather than identifying the current Appios company as operator.

Google Sites hosting is a concrete platform fact, not proof that the developer paid nothing or that the app is fraudulent. The concern is that buyers of an authenticator face a broken primary privacy route and inconsistent operator information. The Apple label declares identifiers, usage data and diagnostics not linked to identity; this investigation did not inspect secret storage, network traffic or the claimed encryption.

Native contact section of the Apple-linked Authie policy retains the SBA support domain. E9.
Actual cropped contact paragraph of the Apple-linked Authie policy, showing the legacy SBA domain. E9.
Apple-linked privacy page Privacy link inside the description Terms link inside the description

E8-E11/E34. Captures were inspected after cookie overlays were dismissed.

Follow the product and policy connections

Solid links in this diagram are exact current account membership, linked policy references or matching product IDs. Registry and named-developer leads are qualified separately. A legacy contact, policy mismatch or common service provider can reflect a transfer or contractor relationship; it does not, by itself, establish common beneficial ownership.

Diagram of Appios apps and their SBA, ERSIN policy, named-developer and Android associations. Each edge states its evidence type; common ownership is not asserted.
Editorial connection map: direct product/policy links are separated from historical catalogs, statutory-company matching and named-developer leads. E5/E9/E12-E20/E25/E27/E30/E31/E33/E35-E38.

E5/E9/E12-E20/E25/E27/E30/E31/E33.

SBA TECH: a legacy product trail, not a proven Apple ban

A secondary Appstor page names SBA TECH for Authly and links exact Apple ID 6476198484 plus developer 1668818748. Its catalog also retains Gun Identifier 6737149324 and Antique Identifier 6739430251 under SBA, while current Apple records place all three under Appios. Authly’s own still-linked support domain independently corroborates a legacy SBA association. The catalog’s contradictory zero-app summary is not used as proof of a transfer or removal date.

The old SBA US developer URL returned 404 and its exact Apple developer lookup returned no records. VPN Guard Fast Proxy 1668818746, retained in the legacy catalog, also returned 404 and no lookup result in US/DE/IE. These establish checked unavailability, not an Apple account-termination notice or fraud finding.

Companies House lists an exact-name UK company, SBA TECH LTD 13831471, incorporated 6 January 2022 and dissolved 31 December 2024. It names Batuhan Yalcin as director/secretary and a person with 75%or more share/voting control. The legacy sbatech.uk domain was registered on the same incorporation date, according to Nominet; its registrant is redacted. The public app policy does not publish a company number, so the publisher-to-UK-entity match remains a registry lead.

A search-indexed professional profile for Batuhan Yalçın states an Appios Bilişim affiliation and lists related authenticator/Second Sim/VPN work. Direct profile retrieval was blocked. That is a self-reported professional association, not a statutory ownership record for Appios or proof of who controlled the Apple accounts. The record does not support describing a banned developer’s return as confirmed.

Companies House’s exact-name SBA TECH LTD record13831471 shows dissolution on31 December2024. Company dissolution and Apple account enforcement are separate events. E16.
Companies House’s exact-name SBA TECH LTD record13831471 shows dissolution on31 December2024. Company dissolution and Apple account enforcement are separate events. E16.
Product-history matches and their source strength
Exact productCurrent primary Apple recordLegacy evidence / interpretation
Authly /6476198484Appios1796567865Appstor SBA1668818748 + current Authie policy domain; legacy association
Gun Identifier /6737149324Appios1796567865Appstor names SBA TECH; secondary association
Antique Identifier /6739430251Appios1796567865Appstor names SBA TECH; secondary association
VPN Guard Fast Proxy /1668818746No current US/DE/IE software matchLegacy SBA catalog; three-store pages404
SBA TECH LTD /13831471UK company register, not an Apple account IDExact-name registry lead; legal entity linkage incomplete
Legacy Authly product catalog Former SBA developer catalog SBA TECH LTD company record SBA company control record Professional profile, indexed association only

E9/E15-E19/E30/E31/E33/E38. Company and publisher identities remain qualified separately.

The second Appios authenticator points to ERSIN LTD

Apple currently lists Auth Authenticator 1554760348 on the same Appios account, bundle com.vault.password-manager. It offers a separate weekly $9.99, monthly $14.99 and yearly $49.99 purchase list. At an unchanged weekly rate, its estimated yearly equivalent is$519.48; no payment or feature equivalence was tested.

A secondary FoxData record for the same exact ID and bundle retains the name Authy Authenticator. That strengthens the brand-name history concern, but it is not a dated Apple screenshot or a verified name-change event. Its old displayed version date cannot establish when the title changed. Current Apple uses Auth Authenticator.

Its description links Google Sites policies named auth-privacy and auth-terms. Both identify ERSIN LTD as service provider, while Apple identifies Appios. The privacy page also first says precise location is not gathered, then describes device-location collection. These are operator and disclosure inconsistencies on the linked page, not proof of observed location access.

Apple separately lists developer ERSIN LTD 1518602060 with five current products and a full Turkish legal seller, ERSIN GIDA TARIM URUNLERI SERACILIK AMBALAJ VE NAKLIYAT HIZMETLERI SANAYI TICARET LTD. STI. The policy’s matching display name is a lead to clarify. No contract, app-transfer record, binary match or common owner was recovered.

Auth Authenticator /1554760348. Current original Apple artwork; Appios account. E5/E12.
Auth Authenticator /1554760348. Current original Apple artwork; Appios account. E5/E12.
Current second authenticator on Apple Its linked privacy policy names ERSIN LTD Current ERSIN Apple developer account Secondary old-title record

E5/E12-E14/E20/E27. The current names and separate numeric accounts are not conflated.

A named developer attribution leads to a separate account

Two Appios products, Volume Booster 6501970701 and Decibel Meter 6670328692, retain copyright attribution to Tuğrul Hakan Gençtürk in Apple listings. Apple’s catalog also gives com.tuhage bundle prefixes for those apps, Second Phone Number 6479579768 and Notify 6742913066. Copyright/bundle strings are development-history clues, not shareholder records.

Apple separately identifies Tugrul Hakan Gencturk as developer 1726770886, currently publishing Chataibot — AI Chat 6765872990. This is a second verified account with the matching professional name. The association does not establish that it controls Appios, that the account was created to evade enforcement, or that its chatbot is fraudulent.

The separate chatbot’s Apple label says Data Not Collected, while its own linked policy describes device identifiers, AI-request processing, purchase records, account retention and chat metadata. That published disclosure mismatch merits clarification on its own terms. Actual collection was not measured, and brand/model names in a chatbot subtitle alone do not establish impersonation.

Chataibot — AI Chat /6765872990, separate developer1726770886. Current original Apple icon; not an Authy comparison. E25.
Chataibot — AI Chat /6765872990, separate developer1726770886. Current original Apple icon; not an Authy comparison. E25.
Separate Tugrul Hakan Gencturk account Chataibot on Apple Chatbot policy describing retained records

E5/E25/E26/E35-E37/E39. Exact copyright/bundle/account associations and published privacy disclosures; no common-owner conclusion.

The same legal company also publishes on Android

Google Play developer 5154758966327353070 identifies the same full Appios legal company and Kocaeli location. Authly Authenticator uses package com.apps.authenticator.authie and displays 100K+ downloads. The Play catalog also lists an Authenticator App, Deepsearch, Forms for Google Forms, Universal TV Remote Control and Brushes For Sketchbook. These are confirmed portfolio associations, not a fraud verdict on every app.

The Android Authly description repeats references to iCloud, Apple Watch and Face ID. The page does not explain their Android scope. This is a cross-platform presentation question, not a finding that those integrations are technically impossible or that they were tested. Google Play’s data-safety panel lists financial information, app-performance information and device identifiers as potentially collected/shared.

Deep Search’s service policies explicitly name Appios as operator. Its Android product remains listed, while iOS ID 6747826215 returned 404 and no software lookup match in US/DE/IE on 13 November. The iOS historical Appios attribution is retained by secondary catalogs, with the current service’s own company declaration providing additional context. No Apple enforcement reason or service-result test was obtained.

Native Google Play view: Authly Authenticator under the Appios company. The install count is the store’s displayed100K+ range, not an independently measured download total. E21.
Native Google Play view: Authly Authenticator under the Appios company. The install count is the store’s displayed100K+ range, not an independently measured download total. E21.
Authly on Google Play Appios Android developer page Deep Search service policy identifies Appios Deepsearch Android product

E21-E24/E32. Public pages only; no app installation or purchase.

All 13 current Apple apps on the Appios account

Apple’s German and Irish provider panels identify APPIOS BILISIM TEKNOLOJILERI SANAYI TICARET LIMITED SIRKETI as a trader, DUNS 595951912, in Basiskele/Kocaeli, Turkey. The company homepage and Google Play business disclosure name the same legal company and location. This is business-location evidence, not an inference from a person’s name.

This table is the exact US software catalog returned for developer 1796567865 on 13 November 2026. Listing another product here establishes current publisher membership only. The report does not accuse all 13 apps of fraud, infer their revenues, or date the current account from the oldest product’s release.

Current Appios catalog —13 exact app IDs; primary Apple source E5
App / Apple IDBundle IDApp release date
Translator* / 1488032953com.appilf.translator2019-12-06
Auth Authenticator / 1554760348com.vault.password-manager2021-03-27
Second Sim - Receive SMS / 1609762387com.secondsim.sms2022-02-25
VPN - SuperX Unlimited Proxy / 1637261649com.secgin.supervpn2022-08-09
Authly / 6476198484com.authie.authenticator.app2024-01-31
Second Phone Number² / 6479579768com.tuhage.SecondPhone2024-03-27
Volume Booster & Water Ejector / 6501970701com.tuhage.volume.booster2024-04-30
Decibel Meter™ / 6670328692com.tuhage.decibelMeter2024-09-05
Gun Identifier / 6737149324com.app.gun.identifier2024-10-22
Antique Identifier / 6739430251com.antique.identifier.ios2024-12-19
Notify - AI Note Taker / 6742913066com.tuhage.notify2025-03-10
Pixize Eraser Object Removal / 6754662332com.appios.photo2025-11-14
PDF Editor ™ / 6784022308com.appios.pdf.editor2026-07-04
Open the current Appios Apple account

E3-E5/E11/E21. App-specific business evidence; no ownership inference from names or old release dates.

Confusing names and an inaccessible privacy policy

For the added Shield Apps case, the concrete review issues are Authy/Duo in the app identity, Google-colour branding, unqualified #1 product badges, the Gmail privacy-button DNS failure, and the commercial non-trader disclosure. Google and Dropbox guidance also restrict misleading brand affiliations; the existing independence disclaimers are preserved in the case-specific sections. No blanket infringement verdict is made for all15 products.

Twilio expressly lists AUTHY as a trademark. Its guidance allows accurate, limited plain-text references, but rejects confusingly similar names and misleading affiliation. The near-identical Authly name, together with two explicit user-confusion reports and the second app’s retained Authy-title record, supports a concrete brand-confusion complaint. A licence search or legal infringement judgment was not obtained.

Apple’s 2.3.1 addresses misleading marketing, 2.3.7 calls for unique and accurate names, 4.1 addresses copycats and 5.2.1 covers misleading or copycat representations. Guideline 5.1.1(i) requires an easily accessible privacy policy link. The broken Apple privacy-button target is a directly reproducible mismatch with that requirement.

The available evidence supports a misleading-name and privacy-transparency warning. It does not establish stolen authentication secrets, malicious code, manipulated rankings, a common controller behind all named accounts, or a confirmed return after an Apple ban.

Twilio trademark guidance, including AUTHY Apple App Review Guidelines

E1/E2/E8/E12/E20/E28/E29. Editorial presentation assessment and rule comparisons are distinguished from enforcement or court decisions. Added account: E40/E42/E63/E65/E66.

View the dates and timeline
  1. Date printed on the Authie policy

    Effective-date text only; not a verified page publication or launch-title capture. E9/E10.

  2. Apple records Authly app’s first release

    Exact app 6476198484 release field. The original launch name/icon were not independently recovered. E5.

  3. A reviewer explicitly contrasts AuthY and AuthLY

    Mcfly_R reports confusion and objects to subscriptions. Source page 7; current Apple text. E1/E2.

  4. Exact-name SBA TECH LTD record dissolved

    Companies House 13831471, a qualified registry lead. This is not an Apple account-termination date. E16.

  5. Second reviewer describes looking for Authy

    HazeFDC reports noticing the extra L and says no money was paid. E1/E2.

  6. Date printed on the second authenticator’s policies

    The live linked pages identify ERSIN LTD; that effective-date text does not establish a transfer date. E13/E14.

  7. Current listings, company records and legal links checked

    Authly and Auth Authenticator resolve under Appios in exact-ID US/DE/IE queries. Appios US catalog has 13 apps; Deepsearch iOS and legacy SBA VPN are unavailable in all three checked stores. Publisher/control conclusions remain bounded to the evidence.

CHECK THE SOURCES

The records behind this report.

This expanded dossier combines the independent investigation of two separate publisher groups with all14 pages of the supplied Authly analysis, in original order. The added Shield Apps case uses fresh US/DE/IE Apple pages, all15 current account products, original Apple artwork, rendered legal pages, a working product site, registry/DNS records and official brand references. Historical archive replay failures and secondary-only product leads are identified. No app was installed, no purchase was made and no real authentication secret was imported.

Open source files, archive links and checksums

E1 / Supplied Authly analysis and original Apple captures

All 14 supplied pages, captured 13 November 2026 at 09:25:02 UTC. Pages 1-3: identity/prices/provider; 4: portfolio; 5-6: original promotions; 7: two reviews; 9-14: native US/IE captures. Original-source checksum independently calculated.

SHA-256: 9944b97685857c9174787284cfcfb4cdcd257d31b69dfbd2eb7836c039b8c3f7

E2 / Authly: current US Apple product page

Name, subtitle, subscription labels, two confusion reviews, description still naming Authie, privacy link and version history read directly from Apple. A later browser capture was rate-limited and is not presented as a product screenshot. Retrieved 2026-11-13 T 10:09:58.906063+00:00; HTTP 200.

Open source ↗

SHA-256: c6aec9d846eea0e54e91c4e474b386f773bb2ea6283c47f75cbefe8267850f69

E3 / Authly: German trader disclosure

Apple identifies APPIOS BILISIM TEKNOLOJILERI SANAYI TICARET LIMITED SIRKETI as trader, DUNS 595951912, Basiskele/Kocaeli, Turkey. Residential-style street/contact details are not transcribed into the narrative. Retrieved 2026-11-13 T 10:09:58.758543+00:00; HTTP 200.

Open source ↗

SHA-256: ce641ee8eae6fcfe0fc0ebfd302528c6bcca203986fd9afe4e1866457c22c274

E4 / Authly: Irish listing and provider record

Fresh successful retry corroborates the same legal provider and Turkish business location, and weekly EUR 7.99/monthly EUR 14.99/yearly EUR 44.99. The earlier HTTP 429 attempt is retained privately, not treated as removal. Retrieved 2026-11-13 T 10:19:12.024470+00:00; HTTP 200.

Open source ↗

SHA-256: a95eca4675452cec4a345720e346bf331809099b0332333b81cbb05c0c861a15

E5 / Exact Apple developer catalog: Appios Bilisim

Developer 1796567865 returns 13 software records with exact app/bundle IDs and common legal seller. Release dates describe the apps, not necessarily when this account acquired them. Retrieved 2026-11-13 T 10:09:59.364576+00:00; HTTP 200.

Open source ↗

SHA-256: 81816d8881e716fcf54e50b7d196df5dc3a02ae2876c98a2365e04b848ad9b6b

E6 / Official Twilio Authy identity and artwork

Apple exact-ID record: Twilio Authy, app 494168017, Authy Inc., developer 494168021, bundle com.authy, price 0. Artwork retrieved from original Apple URL. Matched to Twilio official download page, E7. Retrieved 2026-11-13 T 10:09:59.228188+00:00; HTTP 200.

Open source ↗

SHA-256: e5b6629b865403723a851170b2ffa353926519fc23b718d830281492a602789c

E7 / Twilio official Authy download page

Official product reference, distinct from Authly and Appios. Download link points to the Authy app, not app 6476198484. Retrieved 2026-11-13 T 10:09:59.377821+00:00; HTTP 200.

Open source ↗

SHA-256: fe5f477cf8a066f100ff62e6e44f4c2cb485650b895177ee53346cc1c1dce2c1

E8 / The linked privacy page returns 404

Apple privacy-button target https://appios.com.tr/privacy.html returns HTTP 404 with a page-not-found response. The working company homepage links the same broken route. Retrieved 2026-11-13 T 10:09:58.798793+00:00; HTTP 404.

Open source ↗

SHA-256: 4fff82402afbe2bc9af26f9a86f16ffd47c9bb2629209430b15d2a66f8343418

E9 / Authie privacy policy: legacy SBA support contact

Live Google Sites page linked from Authly description. Names Authie, leaves the opening provider-name slots blank, and gives a support contact at sbatech.uk. Effective-date text: 18 January 2024; this is not proof of the publication/capture date. Retrieved 2026-11-13 T 10:09:59.089772+00:00; HTTP 200.

Open source ↗

SHA-256: d8e8b18d87837427bdd977e8135d8512ce52bcc12517de1ef80f737941e0a90f

E10 / Authie terms: blank rights-holder and legacy contact

Live Google Sites terms linked from Authly description. Rights-holder name is missing in its ownership sentence; contact domain sbatech.uk. No contract, transfer date or current common controller is disclosed. Retrieved 2026-11-13 T 10:09:59.301464+00:00; HTTP 200.

Open source ↗

SHA-256: c85c0556e61d472be925b92c8ae7ffa9f64da60421eec1c157c3f04ba27a6920

E11 / Appios company website

Working dedicated company website identifies the same Turkish legal company and Basiskele/Kocaeli location as Apple. Its privacy footer links the 404 route. DNS/RDAP checks do not establish a registrant identity for this Turkish domain. Retrieved 2026-11-13 T 10:09:58.832651+00:00; HTTP 200.

Open source ↗

SHA-256: d26b392435f62ff3d34c7ecb8f4ff91d5a5644b543d4aaf9ce85d40f55dff8b9

E12 / Second authenticator on the same Appios account

Current title Auth Authenticator, app 1554760348, bundle com.vault.password-manager. The description points to auth-privacy/auth-terms while Apple privacy button again points to appios.com.tr/privacy.html. US displayed options: weekly 9.99, monthly 14.99, yearly 49.99 dollars. Retrieved 2026-11-13 T 10:11:47.576868+00:00; HTTP 200.

Open source ↗

SHA-256: 03ba6d5715a44843b3540bef836a526b4d7eed8e86feed7d625d084ed91ff88b

E13 / Second authenticator policy names ERSIN LTD

Live Google Sites policy explicitly identifies ERSIN LTD as Service Provider, with a separate support inbox and effective-date text 25 June 2025. This conflicts with the current Apple seller name; the reason is unresolved. Retrieved 2026-11-13 T 10:13:20.421669+00:00; HTTP 200.

Open source ↗

SHA-256: 6d2f804b51441a6657d202cf21e56af876ffa74c9113ed27b5bec531ab78ffc4

E14 / Second authenticator terms repeat ERSIN LTD

Companion Google Sites terms identify ERSIN LTD and state that the page was generated by App Privacy Policy Generator. A template credit or policy name alone is not proof of shared account control. Retrieved 2026-11-13 T 10:13:20.510419+00:00; HTTP 200.

Open source ↗

SHA-256: b6676bf2acf08770c52cba82e7da92a7f752f1e659bd7f6a256274cc70277a0e

E15 / Secondary exact-product catalog: Authly under SBA TECH

Appstor page names SBA TECH, points to Apple product 6476198484 and developer catalog 1668818748. Its record is a secondary, undated legacy attribution, not an Apple transfer confirmation. Retrieved 2026-11-13 T 10:11:47.964725+00:00; HTTP 200.

Open source ↗

SHA-256: d262f201c35dcfbf52184fb5933c6f80bba9750d080ae98075076a85b614bd07

E16 / Companies House: exact-name SBA TECH LTD record

Official UK record 13831471: incorporated 6 January 2022; dissolved 31 December 2024. This is a registry lead matching the catalog publisher name. No company number was recovered from the legacy Authly policy or domain registrant; an exact legal-entity match is not established. Retrieved 2026-11-13 T 10:13:19.984570+00:00; HTTP 200.

Open source ↗

SHA-256: 8b026d60053075e5e7945da421c5eb2045a3a4179741753e45c310d09908e1ce

E17 / Companies House: SBA TECH officers

Official exact-name company record lists Batuhan Yalcin as director/secretary. Personal date of birth and correspondence address are excluded from the editorial narrative. Retrieved 2026-11-13 T 10:13:20.081477+00:00; HTTP 200.

Open source ↗

SHA-256: 9f49e9392b3478fdd82cc3bf84288408a3cd4cd5cd7a46122b6e6d136077cc70

E18 / Companies House: declared significant control

The same record lists Batuhan Yalcin with 75%or more of shares/voting rights and appointment/removal rights. This establishes what that company filed, not ownership of Appios or an Apple-account ban. Retrieved 2026-11-13 T 10:13:20.039943+00:00; HTTP 200.

Open source ↗

SHA-256: be0d7a820b1de3ba465e5fce2dabdf458853f1f56b12759b322c55993e4da4b0

E19 / Former SBA Apple catalog lookup

US exact developer 1668818748 lookup returned zero records. Its developer URL also returned 404. These observations do not establish Apple account termination or a reason. Retrieved 2026-11-13 T 10:13:19.884802+00:00; HTTP 200.

Open source ↗

SHA-256: 7f5ce663b726607eae2fde2a6dc438052ac0d1681e636de7cc3377c0bb77e047

E20 / Secondary history: same second app named Authy Authenticator

FoxData retains app 1554760348, bundle com.vault.password-manager, Appios seller and former title Authy Authenticator. Its displayed version/date is 1.3/24 Nov 2025; it is not a captured date for a name-change event. Current Apple title is Auth Authenticator. Retrieved 2026-11-13 T 10:13:21.469337+00:00; HTTP 200.

Open source ↗

SHA-256: a0678fcf1496ab5cba87c715f67935040bf290fb6fe84855edc7f764b96885e3

E21 / Official Google Play: Authly Authenticator

Package com.apps.authenticator.authie; developer 5154758966327353070, same full Appios legal company and Kocaeli address. Displays 100K+ downloads. Description repeats iCloud/Apple Watch/Face ID wording; data-safety summary lists financial information, app performance and device identifiers. Retrieved 2026-11-13 T 10:09:59.654487+00:00; HTTP 200.

Open source ↗

SHA-256: 57cfa2637c579cd18dda2ec9e7e356014f50fce02d505d1eb64cca5119b5b8f8

E22 / Official Appios Android publisher catalog

Exact Google Play developer 5154758966327353070 displays Authly, Authenticator App, Deepsearch AI People Search, Forms for Google Forms, Universal TV Remote Control and Brushes For Sketchbook. This is portfolio context, not six proven scams. Retrieved 2026-11-13 T 10:11:48.922046+00:00; HTTP 200.

Open source ↗

SHA-256: f831bef5d4423b2332e8a817c03fd0a28418cc3b528fb9f0bdfaf47d4a4fb3f1

E23 / Deep Search service policy names Appios

The service policy identifies the same full Appios legal company and company-domain contact. This is a direct business declaration, not an outbound-link ownership inference. Retrieved 2026-11-13 T 10:10:00.314965+00:00; HTTP 200.

Open source ↗

SHA-256: 77f932f7fb21f5df29d0879c15692cc0d2ae9005935b09f1230377b2b1709cce

E24 / Deep Search terms name the same operator

The terms identify Appios and Turkish/Kocaeli governing jurisdiction. No paid service or face-search result was tested. Retrieved 2026-11-13 T 10:11:49.046963+00:00; HTTP 200.

Open source ↗

SHA-256: ce2abb5cf76bc3fc0323c51711b658b93dee6a616dfaaa4ed168fb525ead4fab

E25 / Separate personal Apple account: Tugrul Hakan Gencturk

Exact Apple developer 1726770886 returns Chataibot app 6765872990, bundle co.chataibot.app. Some current Appios apps retain copyright attribution to the same full name and use com.tuhage bundle prefixes. This supports a developer-attribution lead, not proven common beneficial ownership. Retrieved 2026-11-13 T 10:11:48.056836+00:00; HTTP 200.

Open source ↗

SHA-256: 54ac1fa188df7e53c3a44b6a22eec0f6460887e2904e22dfae6ec64eed8210bd

E26 / Chataibot privacy: retained account and purchase records

Apple-linked policy names device identifiers, third-party AI processing, purchase records and retention periods. App Store page declares Data Not Collected. This is a disclosure mismatch requiring clarification; no traffic/binary analysis establishes actual behavior. Retrieved 2026-11-13 T 10:11:48.187378+00:00; HTTP 200.

Open source ↗

SHA-256: ac835371249f72e3b8d3125f7c1fefe770a00d08e4197c539b9d02987edc933c

E27 / Separate ERSIN LTD Apple account

Apple developer 1518602060 returns five apps with full seller ERSIN GIDA TARIM URUNLERI SERACILIK AMBALAJ VE NAKLIYAT HIZMETLERI SANAYI TICARET LTD. STI. Same display name as Appios Auth Authenticator policy is a lead; no contract or shared controller was recovered. Retrieved 2026-11-13 T 10:16:40.287880+00:00; HTTP 200.

Open source ↗

SHA-256: 92ea06b9b30c6652635555f3bf4ae8e90c81e4b08b12396d7bc6ac95204bc12e

E28 / Twilio trademark guidance: AUTHY and confusingly similar names

AUTHY appears in Twilio trademark list. Guidance permits accurate fair-use references but rejects confusingly similar product names and misleading affiliation. No permission record or adjudicated infringement decision was obtained. Retrieved 2026-11-13 T 10:13:21.897101+00:00; HTTP 200.

Open source ↗

SHA-256: 161e337fc7589ec465be23dbc8b753715947643db9d5ba4967c32027dfd589f0

E29 / Apple rules on accurate names and privacy links

Relevant provisions include 2.3.1/2.3.7 Accurate Metadata,4.1 Copycats,5.1.1(i) accessible privacy policy and 5.2.1 misleading/copycat names. These are compliance questions tied to observed presentation, not a legal finding. Retrieved 2026-11-13 T 10:13:20.819027+00:00; HTTP 200.

Open source ↗

SHA-256: 9dd55caf94bd259fc1b44b0cdd6b2e18c206edcae91f0521c0c9118451fa1bbc

E30 / Second legacy-product match: Gun Identifier

Secondary catalog names SBA TECH and links exact Apple app 6737149324; current exact Apple catalog attributes it to Appios. A secondary publisher-history association, with no verified transfer date. Retrieved 2026-11-13 T 10:19:11.344919+00:00; HTTP 200.

Open source ↗

SHA-256: 022f940e2ec305b27e194a8d2716b349817e586a3c460e43ab497799c390e2a6

E31 / Third legacy-product match: Antique Identifier

Secondary catalog names SBA TECH and links exact Apple app 6739430251; current exact Apple catalog attributes it to Appios. The repeated matches strengthen product-history association but do not prove an enforcement-evasion timeline. Retrieved 2026-11-13 T 10:19:11.337643+00:00; HTTP 200.

Open source ↗

SHA-256: 22b29d3a53cef71a8dc3c1477cd8644f0c26d16dcd84fe5a01e481e42e25726d

E32 / Deepsearch on Google Play under the same company

Official current Android product lists the same Appios publisher. The corresponding iOS app 6747826215 returned 404 in US/DE/IE and no exact-ID lookup result in those three stores on 13 Nov 2026; absence does not establish why it disappeared. Retrieved 2026-11-13 T 10:11:48.646985+00:00; HTTP 200.

Open source ↗

SHA-256: 8a55e429f7a4d3ef00afdb5a3b1d0ca3cd5f50a89e25cb129c17727e728b00b5

E33 / Nominet: legacy support-domain registration

sbatech.uk registered 6 January 2022 through GoDaddy; current registrant identity is redacted. Nameservers point to Cloudflare. Registration on the same day as the exact-name company incorporation is an additional chronological clue, not a registrant-owner confirmation. Retrieved 2026-11-13 T 10:11:48.933234+00:00; HTTP 200.

Open source ↗

SHA-256: a6848516e3f3dd66ef68403d29566e9573f817a964bc0c414584cdea6ac29898

E34 / Legacy Appios contact route also returns 404

The old contact.html route returns 404. The homepage has a working displayed company-contact section; the report does not claim all contact methods are unavailable. Retrieved 2026-11-13 T 10:16:40.877207+00:00; HTTP 404.

Open source ↗

SHA-256: f850ba6d253df75807bb2f079ce979e0af9fc411555f61460011e8f49abcbc5f

E35 / Appios product retains named developer copyright

Current Apple listing for Volume Booster6501970701 includes copyright Tuğrul Hakan Gençtürk. Retrieved 2026-11-13T10:27:06.164242+00:00; HTTP200.

Open source ↗

SHA-256: 3ec43e7e7ae2c0393e71a44e52b1b88bfb8c61167dade020682916d3e1f4ca63

E36 / Second Appios copyright match

Current Apple listing for Decibel Meter6670328692 includes the same full named copyright attribution. Retrieved 2026-11-13T10:27:06.130856+00:00; HTTP200.

Open source ↗

SHA-256: e8ebd8282ee25ad50b06849a29c4a6d545447f083139dae1e9ae83c1deec2cbd

E37 / Separate chatbot Apple privacy label

Current Apple listing for Chataibot6765872990, developer1726770886, declares Data Not Collected; compare its directly linked policy E26. Retrieved 2026-11-13T10:11:47.511279+00:00; HTTP200.

Open source ↗

SHA-256: 216fd4beb348cf59ea3d16dbaab0dbac23569f626802b55e48db01972038e77e

E38 / Self-reported professional Appios association

Search-indexed primary professional-profile snippet identifies Batuhan Yalçın, Appios Bilişim LTD, Kocaeli and authenticator/Second Sim/VPN projects. Direct retrieval returned999 and was not bypassed. Self-reporting is not a corporate ownership or identity-verification record.

Open source ↗

E39 / Apple privacy-disclosure definitions

Apple describes collection as off-device transmission allowing access beyond real-time request servicing, and defines device identifiers and purchase history. Used as context for the chatbot policy/label mismatch, not as a measurement of actual app traffic.

Open source ↗

SHA-256: b39771cf9c5f719adb45d36f549052f86edd1cb39d72209ee1208c3d2a1edf4a

E40 / Second publisher: US iPhone Authy-name listing

Current title Authenticator App - Authy, 2FA; subtitle Duo Authy Authenticator App; seller 满 李, not Authy Inc. Eight ratings, 3.9 displayed. No explicit Authy-confusion complaint appeared in the visible selected reviews; positive and setup-difficulty reviews were both preserved privately. Retrieved 2026-11-13T10:45:12.532671+00:00; HTTP 200.

Open source ↗

SHA-256: b3d348d54f5c569ed01d7287ac600cea3327b68e7d4819117c8d98ac688b9f41

E41 / Second publisher: US Mac listing and original promotional artwork

Same numeric App ID; native Mac page, version 3.7.8, 29 ratings and 3.7 displayed. Actual loaded browser screenshot and three original Mac promotional images retained. iPhone API version 3.7.5 is platform-specific, not the Mac version. Retrieved 2026-11-13T10:45:12.517297+00:00; HTTP 200.

Open source ↗

SHA-256: 3a29827981d896b710b8247c929c1729cccb05ce9cf0d47cff257bd3315ca257

E42 / MAN LI: German provider disclosure

Apple identifies MAN LI as provider and says the provider has not identified as a trader; no provider country/address appears in the inspected panel. English-language Irish page corroborates the notice. This is Apple disclosure, not an independent legal classification. Retrieved 2026-11-13T10:45:12.559563+00:00; HTTP 200.

Open source ↗

SHA-256: 159d4d74493a4de4648db976304edc1e5c47051bef8b873aeb3edfa890883280

E43 / MAN LI: Irish provider disclosure

English provider name MAN LI and non-trader notice; English subtitle retains Duo and Authy. Retrieved 2026-11-13T10:45:12.508035+00:00; HTTP 200.

Open source ↗

SHA-256: f54e95fcb879370520c932f42eb677667a5bdc2735f9d5ff0e91919a722d72d4

E44 / Full current Shield Apps / 满 李 catalog: 15 apps

Apple lookup for developer 1653727587 returns 15 software products, with matching numeric artist IDs and exact bundle IDs. Generic utility membership is not evidence of fraud. The macSoftware-only lookup returned the artist without product rows; this was not treated as an empty account. Retrieved 2026-11-13T10:45:47.247426+00:00; HTTP 200.

Open source ↗

SHA-256: 791a564fc4dfa2c2adbfa82a01c36164487d165062a15c482aa9fa644569b1b2

E45 / Shield Apps homepage connects the authenticator and utility catalog

Working dedicated product site, direct App Store IDs and the same public support mailbox as developer responses/policies. This confirms the Shield Apps branding association to the observed account; it is not a connection to the separate Appios account. Retrieved 2026-11-13T10:45:47.232992+00:00; HTTP 200.

Open source ↗

SHA-256: 7a49364d7c8cc5bf53f3b81d1c722a016382644f5db7ad4c558627003b9a81a2

E46 / Rendered Authenticator privacy policy names LI MAN

JavaScript-rendered Notion page read successfully; names LI MAN, states local/iCloud storage and no personal/usage collection, support at the Shield Apps mailbox. Effective date text January 16, 2024 is not a verified publication date. Native text retained; cookie/loading overlay captures excluded. Retrieved 2026-11-13T10:45:47.299573+00:00; HTTP 200.

Open source ↗

SHA-256: da96e850fa8e66b3c837afb22033ad4018fad79b6bfce502c5a3ad7c6ef147ee

E47 / Rendered Authenticator terms name LI MAN

Rendered public Notion terms identify LI MAN; personal/non-commercial revocable licence, unspecified operator jurisdiction and general modification/termination clauses. These do not prove credential theft or a scam; the third-party operator is clear in the legal text. Retrieved 2026-11-13T10:45:47.225447+00:00; HTTP 200.

Open source ↗

SHA-256: b2aeebb34b229dd90de02325b57dc5528e91b0a530ba18fae0c9bf4a0cecae7e

E48 / Shield Apps domain registry: declared Hubei, CN

Authoritative .top RDAP reached through rdap.org retains registrant country CN and region hu bei; registrant name/contact redacted. Domain registered November 18, 2025, Alibaba Cloud registrar IANA1599, HiChina nameservers. This establishes domain-registration geography, not seller nationality or a verified business residence. Retrieved 2026-11-13T10:46:44.912861+00:00; HTTP 200.

Open source ↗

SHA-256: 0a186305040f012c28aa4906a26a2c2aaa02f2e5c1bf13f4417bd6540fffae59

E49 / Official Gmail icon and publisher reference

Original artwork and exact official product ID retrieved from Apple; comparison preserves differences and does not claim a measured similarity percentage or an adjudicated licence violation. Retrieved 2026-11-13T10:46:44.156210+00:00; HTTP 200.

Open source ↗

SHA-256: 8ea87a8e3cf00c600588bb019b5c905d4710bfd6432b1f0c8a517bf84c303fc5

E50 / Official Google Drive icon and publisher reference

Original artwork and exact official product ID retrieved from Apple; comparison preserves differences and does not claim a measured similarity percentage or an adjudicated licence violation. Retrieved 2026-11-13T10:46:44.351865+00:00; HTTP 200.

Open source ↗

SHA-256: ceb50b5fda9df9fcf23f8443c8e1a4fe4b68f5f8e6241a7075235df42c670fd6

E51 / Official Google Docs icon and publisher reference

Original artwork and exact official product ID retrieved from Apple; comparison preserves differences and does not claim a measured similarity percentage or an adjudicated licence violation. Retrieved 2026-11-13T10:46:44.155978+00:00; HTTP 200.

Open source ↗

SHA-256: 773cfed365498771d3d12fb70d794ac9d9b89b47924a2024a945a11e61745d6e

E52 / Official Google Photos icon and publisher reference

Original artwork and exact official product ID retrieved from Apple; comparison preserves differences and does not claim a measured similarity percentage or an adjudicated licence violation. Retrieved 2026-11-13T10:46:44.351596+00:00; HTTP 200.

Open source ↗

SHA-256: eda509a6ecf1759e66b543588d96704d0f0922903eb44f7fc14467a70d05c48a

E53 / Official Dropbox icon and publisher reference

Original artwork and exact official product ID retrieved from Apple; comparison preserves differences and does not claim a measured similarity percentage or an adjudicated licence violation. Retrieved 2026-11-13T10:46:44.155743+00:00; HTTP 200.

Open source ↗

SHA-256: 792fcfbcbbd3b0975b34777f37a2f40e2c220706a4e660b26f010f283b731175

E54 / Official YouTube icon and publisher reference

Original artwork and exact official product ID retrieved from Apple; comparison preserves differences and does not claim a measured similarity percentage or an adjudicated licence violation. Retrieved 2026-11-13T10:46:44.156038+00:00; HTTP 200.

Open source ↗

SHA-256: 577afb01314bacdf3613ec67c4149a24fd12ae73ec64649a17ff3641b4d65710

E55 / Official Duo Mobile icon and publisher reference

Original artwork and exact official product ID retrieved from Apple; comparison preserves differences and does not claim a measured similarity percentage or an adjudicated licence violation. Retrieved 2026-11-13T10:46:44.503037+00:00; HTTP 200.

Open source ↗

SHA-256: 21bc894cf37fa88edd59918b48e80303d3922053c5d8d3fae2eca58fc5198a78

E56 / Shield Apps Gmail current listing

Current full public listing, original icon/promotional images, purchase list, privacy label, description and visible review excerpts recorded. Existing third-party disclaimers and platform-specific details are preserved in the narrative. Retrieved 2026-11-13T10:46:05.151859+00:00; HTTP 200.

Open source ↗

SHA-256: 947b50be502e0172c47847a73b896f935d4e9bd60796ffbd8ffcd39863a63e4e

E57 / Shield Apps Google Drive current listing

Current full public listing, original icon/promotional images, purchase list, privacy label, description and visible review excerpts recorded. Existing third-party disclaimers and platform-specific details are preserved in the narrative. Retrieved 2026-11-13T10:46:05.243399+00:00; HTTP 200.

Open source ↗

SHA-256: 89826374e08dbfd3de735a08b55c96f8b363b7cdf08c9bb983b451fa79e628db

E58 / Shield Apps Google Docs current listing

Current full public listing, original icon/promotional images, purchase list, privacy label, description and visible review excerpts recorded. Existing third-party disclaimers and platform-specific details are preserved in the narrative. Retrieved 2026-11-13T10:46:05.280420+00:00; HTTP 200.

Open source ↗

SHA-256: 4770ce0085269ba4904a1b4f140cf1c565e09572b79770a2a33fb8cbff07f2c7

E59 / Shield Apps Google Photos current listing

Current full public listing, original icon/promotional images, purchase list, privacy label, description and visible review excerpts recorded. Existing third-party disclaimers and platform-specific details are preserved in the narrative. Retrieved 2026-11-13T10:46:05.825604+00:00; HTTP 200.

Open source ↗

SHA-256: cdab90f47228c95940d52b278db0067906fcc77eeb07ed93b46b1538cdbc9d5d

E60 / Shield Apps Dropbox current listing

Current full public listing, original icon/promotional images, purchase list, privacy label, description and visible review excerpts recorded. Existing third-party disclaimers and platform-specific details are preserved in the narrative. Retrieved 2026-11-13T10:46:05.079618+00:00; HTTP 200.

Open source ↗

SHA-256: 396b45696400b74ebd15ecf848545abf028336a0aa59838d57d3f94d60234ebf

E61 / Shield Apps YouTube dislikes current listing

Current full public listing, original icon/promotional images, purchase list, privacy label, description and visible review excerpts recorded. Existing third-party disclaimers and platform-specific details are preserved in the narrative. Retrieved 2026-11-13T10:46:06.347083+00:00; HTTP 200.

Open source ↗

SHA-256: b10869ee0f0ebaed6dc299ad9a9c86d2e462009b30a5b722e417a5e1e40aed95

E62 / Shield Apps Printer utility current listing

Current full public listing, original icon/promotional images, purchase list, privacy label, description and visible review excerpts recorded. Existing third-party disclaimers and platform-specific details are preserved in the narrative. Retrieved 2026-11-13T10:46:05.781580+00:00; HTTP 200.

Open source ↗

SHA-256: c1516c26881337c15b154465bcb6ba9be9b6e0073c3169aabbfb2053355f2a78

E63 / Gmail privacy-button host fails DNS

Google public DNS returned Status3 (NXDOMAIN) for www.shieldapps.cc; both raw HTTP fetch and native browser failed name resolution. App Store privacy button points to .cc while the description points to a working .top policy. Retrieved 2026-11-13T10:48:12.400189+00:00; HTTP 200.

Open source ↗

SHA-256: 459f5bd50bb76ab82614341a4e243a927f03566a1b9841e33af6c9c70fba5465

E64 / Working Gmail policy at a different .top URL

The description-linked .top privacy page works and identifies Shield Apps; this does not repair the separate broken .cc privacy button. The no-server and Google OAuth/API handling claims were not network-tested. Retrieved 2026-11-13T10:48:12.648052+00:00; HTTP 200.

Open source ↗

SHA-256: 797348a4e85bc26c292dd9b72d0a25f4de1ee3e0e0a7d05ff8dd18c5086ddf69

E65 / Google brand guidance: no misleading affiliation

Official guidance rejects brand use implying nonexistent affiliation/endorsement and incorporation of Google marks in another brand/product identity. Specific permission or licensing records were not obtained. Retrieved 2026-11-13T10:48:12.589362+00:00; HTTP 200.

Open source ↗

SHA-256: 697bb767f91235dbb9d65d8bfcbca25bf96da8adf5337e5daaa5748b468327a7

E66 / Dropbox branding guidance

Official rules reject confusing affiliation, inclusion of Dropbox in a third-party product name, and incorporation of the Dropbox logo into another logo. Contextual permitted uses and any separate permission must be considered; no adjudicated infringement claim is made. Retrieved 2026-11-13T10:46:45.671318+00:00; HTTP 200.

Open source ↗

SHA-256: 95d60bf3341cba5855ecf5d2fbe965a8df9012bc5501a12856426a55a8f43f11

E67 / Twilio: official desktop Authy reached end of life

Twilio dates end of life for the official Windows/macOS/Linux Authy desktop apps to March19,2024. A separate Mac app using Authy in its title is not a restored official desktop edition. Retrieved 2026-11-13T10:49:56.466120+00:00; HTTP 200.

Open source ↗

SHA-256: f64a36fe8365dba0b7bfd7a00023e5ab6428332a93e56b6bd01c4ab6fb43cbfe

E68 / Authy-name listing archive index and replay attempts

Exact-URL CDX returned four captures dated25Dec2025,17Feb2026,6Oct2026 and7Oct2026. All four replay attempts were blocked HTTP429; no historical icon/name/transfer sequence was reconstructed from these hits. A wildcard query returned an empty result; the homepage index timed out. Retrieved 2026-11-13T10:48:14.935078+00:00; HTTP 200.

Open source ↗

SHA-256: 80320e061a9cab8cee74b39720b3e45f260ba830ed5837ba56c0a78638efc430

E69 / Legacy AdBlock ID: current US absence

Exact6449941759 returns zero results in US/DE/IE Apple lookups; current US page404. Search-indexed Appshunter/Apptopia attribute this historical product to 满 李 and the Shield Apps mailbox. Secondary history only; full Appshunter retrieval403 and no confirmed enforcement reason. No account-wide ban is inferred. Retrieved 2026-11-13T10:46:44.450603+00:00; HTTP 200.

Open source ↗

SHA-256: 7f5ce663b726607eae2fde2a6dc438052ac0d1681e636de7cc3377c0bb77e047