App Scam DBBY ALEX KLEBER
← ALL INVESTIGATIONS
Verified model-identity mismatch and branding warning · AI assistants

ChatGPT app scam warning: Sol on screen, Luna in the request.

Our live test caught AI ChatBot - AI Pro Assistant displaying GPT-6.2 Sol while requesting gpt-6-luna and instructing it to claim the Sol identity. Its “Powered by ChatGPT+GPT-6 API” subtitle adds a misleading product association: access to a model is not the same as access to ChatGPT.

Download full dossier · PDF ↓

The live test catches the misleading model label.

We asked: “which exact model are you using. answer in one short sentence”. The app replied: “I am GPT-6.2 Sol, a general-purpose AI model that can help with writing, analysis, coding, and problem-solving.” The recovered request instead specifies gpt-6-luna, and the matching completed response event also reports gpt-6-luna. The request tells the AI to claim the Sol identity.

The captures below show the full question and answer, then the request and reply excerpts with the server context: live.minichatclub.net:80. That server name comes from the request’s Host header; we have not invented a response header. The data was recovered from the running Flutter app’s readable memory (RAM) while TLS encryption remained enabled. No request or model values were changed.

1 · Actual app screenshot: selected GPT-6.2 Sol, our complete model-identity question, and the complete “I am GPT-6.2 Sol…” reply. This is a direct app-window crop with original pixels preserved. E34; E35.
1 · Actual app screenshot: selected GPT-6.2 Sol, our complete model-identity question, and the complete “I am GPT-6.2 Sol…” reply. This is a direct app-window crop with original pixels preserved. E34; E35.
2 · Terminal displaying a saved, formatted excerpt of the observed request. It shows our question, POST route, Host server, model gpt-6-luna and the system instruction asserting Sol. This is a source-excerpt viewer, not an untouched Frida console or proxy capture. Test 04’s request body was only partially recovered. E34; E35.
2 · Terminal displaying a saved, formatted excerpt of the observed request. It shows our question, POST route, Host server, model gpt-6-luna and the system instruction asserting Sol. This is a source-excerpt viewer, not an untouched Frida console or proxy capture. Test 04’s request body was only partially recovered. E34; E35.
3 · Terminal displaying selected fields from the valid response.completed event and the exact reply text. The request’s Host, live.minichatclub.net:80, is repeated as server context; it is not a captured response header. The screenshot includes the same question and reply so the sequence is easy to follow. E34; E35.
3 · Terminal displaying selected fields from the valid response.completed event and the exact reply text. The request’s Host, live.minichatclub.net:80, is repeated as server context; it is not a captured response header. The screenshot includes the same question and reply so the sequence is easy to follow. E34; E35.

E28–E35. Test 04: request headers/body prefix and valid completed response; earlier tests 02 and 03 retain complete request bodies.

ChatGPT is a product, not another name for an API.

Alongside the verified model mismatch, the listing uses “Powered by ChatGPT+GPT-6 API” in its subtitle. ChatGPT is OpenAI’s chatbot product and brand. Ordinary access to a GPT model through an API does not establish that an app is powered by the ChatGPT product. Our test observed a third-party relay, with no ChatGPT sign-in or ChatGPT-plan authorization. Calling this ChatGPT-powered is unsupported by the observed flow.

An accurate claim would identify the provider, API or exact model actually supplied. “Powered by the OpenAI API” or a specific GPT model would require verified delivery; our capture does not authenticate this relay’s upstream provider. A Newrock subscription does not itself provide an OpenAI ChatGPT subscription.

In our assessment, this subtitle exploits the ChatGPT search keyword and familiar product name to attract Apple users to an independent app. The documented buyer confusion makes that concern concrete. Apple rule 2.3.7 prohibits trademark stuffing to manipulate discovery and says subtitles should not reference other apps. We did not measure a ranking benefit or establish the developer’s intent.

OpenAI expressly requires precise, accurate API/model references and prohibits giving its marks greater prominence than the developer’s own branding. Those are the verified rules relevant here. They do not amount to a blanket ban on every third-party ChatGPT integration. Apple should assess this subtitle against both its metadata rules and OpenAI’s branding requirements.

Apple rule 2.3.7 · subtitle and keyword restrictions OpenAI · brand and API/model reference rules OpenAI · ChatGPT integrations require their own authorization

E2; E11; E14; E15; E25; E28–E35; E36.

The buyer’s confusion is explicit.

A Spanish Mac review says the buyer subscribed believing the app was official, then found that it was a third-party product and did not provide the web ChatGPT subscription they expected. The description’s third-party statement remains important context; it did not prevent this reviewer’s reported mistake.

The prominent ChatGPT subtitle and one-click ChatGPT wording promote an association with OpenAI’s product that ordinary model/API access does not establish. This is an attributed buyer experience and our misleading-presentation assessment; the listing’s independent-client statement does not resolve the conflicting product message.

Rendered excerpt of Apple review 12711859345, dated 29 May 2025. Original short Spanish excerpt with labelled English translation; this is a source extraction panel, not a live app screenshot. E11; E22.
Rendered excerpt of Apple review 12711859345, dated 29 May 2025. Original short Spanish excerpt with labelled English translation; this is a source extraction panel, not a live app screenshot. E11; E22.

E2; E11; E22; E25.

VISUAL EVIDENCE

ChatGPT in the subtitle. Newrock on the seller account.

The subtitle says “Powered by ChatGPT+GPT-6 API”. ChatGPT is OpenAI’s chatbot product; using a model through an API does not make an independent app ChatGPT. A buyer reports subscribing under that mistaken impression. These original icons show different designs.

Newrock · independent Mac appNewrock’s current Mac icon: a segmented black cube. The main allegation concerns ChatGPT wording and buyer confusion, not an identical-icon finding. E2; E23.
Newrock’s current Mac icon: a segmented black cube. The main allegation concerns ChatGPT wording and buyer confusion, not an identical-icon finding. E2; E23.
Official ChatGPT · OpenAIOfficial ChatGPT icon from OpenAI OpCo, LLC. Its looped design differs from Newrock’s cube. E23.
Official ChatGPT icon from OpenAI OpCo, LLC. Its looped design differs from Newrock’s cube. E23.

Two apps, one verified Apple developer account.

Apple directly connects the Mac and iPhone products through publisher 1672772882. Their bundles end in chatminimac and chatminiios, they link the same legal documents, and both histories carry the same dated OpenAI-related change note.

The supplied Mac signature verifies under team QXNV8KJ67S. The iPhone binary was not supplied, so that signing team is not assigned to it by assumption. The additional App Store ID in the Mac payload is unresolved.

The Mac test additionally verifies an active request to the minichatclub relay. That service connection is separate from the Apple account connection and does not, by itself, identify another account’s owner. E28–E32.

Original app icons on the verified account map. Apple verifies one account for the Mac and iPhone apps. The Mac relay was observed in the VM; the outbound app ID remains unresolved. No additional common owner or suspended account is established. E5; E6; E18; E24; E28–E32.
Original app icons on the verified account map. Apple verifies one account for the Mac and iPhone apps. The Mac relay was observed in the VM; the outbound app ID remains unresolved. No additional common owner or suspended account is established. E5; E6; E18; E24; E28–E32.
Newrock International · Apple developer 1672772882 iPhone companion · 6471813468

E5; E6; E17; E18; E24.

The Apple rules these findings put in question.

Apple should urgently review the verified Sol/Luna mismatch and the instruction to claim the advertised identity, followed by the official-app confusion and privacy-disclosure conflict. The free-tier findings are reproduced; paid-access failures remain attributed reviews. The developer’s rights-request note is preserved without inventing an Apple enforcement decision.

Observed evidence mapped to current Apple App Review Guidelines
Apple ruleSpecific finding and assessment
2.3 / 2.3.1 · Accurate metadataThe free UI labels the model GPT-6.2 Sol; complete earlier requests and the direct model-question request prefix use gpt-6-luna and instruct the AI to identify as Sol. In Test 04 the visible Sol claim is paired with completed-response metadata naming Luna. This documents inaccurate service presentation. E28–E35; E2; E11.
5.6 · Developer Code of ConductExamine the instruction to claim Sol while requesting Luna, and its observed effect in the direct model-question test. This warrants a misleading-conduct review; criminal fraud and paid-tier delivery were not established. E28–E35.
2.3.7 · Names, subtitles and keywordsThe subtitle “Powered by ChatGPT+GPT-6 API” references another app and blends a product brand with model/API access. Rule 2.3.7 expressly addresses other-app references in subtitles and trademark use to game discovery. In our assessment this warrants a keyword-abuse and misleading-metadata review; no ranking effect was measured. E2; E11; E14; E15; E28–E35.
4.1 / 5.2.1 · Copycats and intellectual propertyReview brand association and authorization in light of the buyer confusion and the seller’s reported OpenAI request. Current icons are visibly different; permission and a legal infringement ruling are not established. E2; E6; E11; E14.
5.1.1 / 5.1.2 · Privacy and data useData Not Collected is difficult to reconcile with a policy describing device/IP collection, account records and analysis. Verify actual retention against Apple’s definitions. E2; E7; E16.
2.1 / 3.1.2 · Functionality and subscriptionsDated reviews report payment without unlocked access, quota errors and unanswered or bounced support. Reproduce current paid flows; these complaints are not verified transactions. E10–E12.
2.3.1 / 3.1.1 · Features and paymentsThe payload contains remote-payment/configuration markers. Their existence does not prove a current prohibited checkout; check the reachable flow and applicable storefront rules. E17; E18; E20.
Apple App Review Guidelines Apple privacy-label definitions OpenAI brand guidance

E14–E16; specific sources in each row.

LOOK FOR YOURSELF

The screenshots tell the story.

Original Apple promotions and store captures follow. The first evidence panel and live-test section show the actual app running in a VM, alongside clearly labelled request and response extracts.

See all 3 additional screenshots
Original Apple promotional image for AI ChatBot - AI Pro Assistant. Retrieved 19 November 2026. E23.
Original Apple promotional image for AI ChatBot - AI Pro Assistant. Retrieved 19 November 2026. E23.
Original Apple promotional image for AI ChatBot - AI Pro Assistants. Retrieved 19 November 2026. E23.
Original Apple promotional image for AI ChatBot - AI Pro Assistants. Retrieved 19 November 2026. E23.
Original Apple promotional image for AI ChatBot - AI Pro Assistants. Retrieved 19 November 2026. E23.
Original Apple promotional image for AI ChatBot - AI Pro Assistants. Retrieved 19 November 2026. E23.
WHAT YOU NEED TO KNOW

Live free-tier test: Sol displayed, Luna requested, and a system instruction tells the model to claim the Sol identity.

Sol on screen, Luna in complete requests.

The free mode displays GPT-6.2 Sol, requests gpt-6-luna and tells the AI to claim the Sol identity. In Test 04, our explicit model question receives a Sol claim, while the matching completed response reports gpt-6-luna. Complete requests remain available from tests 02 and 03; premium tiers were not tested.

E28–E35

E28 E29 E30 E31 E32 E33 E34 E35

ChatGPT branding adds a second misleading message.

The subtitle says “Powered by ChatGPT+GPT-6 API”, although the observed flow establishes a relay/model client rather than access to OpenAI’s ChatGPT product. In our assessment it exploits a familiar search keyword and product association. Apple 2.3.7 restricts other-app references in subtitles and trademark use to manipulate discovery. Ranking effects were not measured.

E2; E11; E14; E15; E25; E28–E35; E36

E2 E11 E14 E15 E25 E28 E29 E30 E31 E32 E33 E34 E35 E36

A buyer says they paid believing it was the official app.

The Spanish Mac review dated 29 May 2025 says the user subscribed thinking the app was official and could not use web ChatGPT. That is a documented confusion complaint, not a transaction reproduced here. The listing’s third-party statement is preserved.

E2; E11; E22

E2 E11 E22

Both app histories report an OpenAI rights-holder request.

The Mac release 1.0.40 and iPhone release 1.1.29, both dated 13 October 2025, say content was changed at the OpenAI copyright holder’s request. These are the developer’s own statements; the underlying notice and its scope were not obtained.

E1; E2; E6

E1 E2 E6

The privacy label and linked policy do not tell the same story.

Apple says Data Not Collected. The linked Chinese-language policy describes collecting device/keychain information and IP addresses, creating account-owner records and internal analysis. It also uses other product names. Retention and actual server handling need reconciliation with Apple’s definition of collection.

E2; E7; E16

E2 E7 E16

The promised model changes depending on which text the buyer reads.

The subtitle names GPT-6, promotions name Sol/Astra, the description names GPT-5.2 and GPT-5, and the paid-plan sentence blends GPT-5.2 Pro with OpenAI 4o. The supplied payload has additional model strings. Their presence does not prove the model actually selected by the server.

E1; E2; E13; E18

E1 E2 E13 E18

Payment and support complaints appear on both products.

Mac reviews describe a paid plan not being honoured, an insufficient_quota error and a returned support email. An iPhone review also reports being locked out after payment. Positive reviews are retained alongside these reports.

E10; E11; E12

E10 E11 E12

The confirmed connection is one seller with two apps.

Apple places the Mac and iPhone products under developer 1672772882 with the same legal links. A separate outbound app ID is unresolved. A reported Gemix infrastructure lead remains qualified; common control of another account is not established.

E5; E6; E18; E19; E24; E26; E27

E5 E6 E18 E19 E24 E26 E27
WHAT IT COSTS

What the Mac subscription costs

Current US Mac purchase labels. The estimated yearly cost of repeated weekly renewal is $155.48, about 5.2 times the listed $29.99 yearly plan. It is an estimate, not an observed charge. The store lists duplicate monthly/yearly labels; eligibility and checkout were not tested.

Estimated yearly cost: $155.48 on weekly renewal.

Continuous renewal at the listed weekly price has an estimated yearly cost of $155.48, about 5.2 times the $29.99 yearly plan. Ireland: €155.48 estimated, compared with €34.99 yearly.

Assumes uninterrupted renewal at unchanged prices without discounts or trial periods; actual calendar-year billing can vary. A price gap alone does not establish fraud.

Prices displayed in the saved listing
Purchase optionUnited StatesIreland
Week Plus · weekly$2.99€2.99
Month Plus · monthly$4.99€5.99
Three Month Plus$17.99€19.99
Year Plus · yearly$29.99€34.99
WHO IS BEHIND IT?

The name on the listing.

App name
AI ChatBot - AI Pro Assistant
Developer / seller
Newrock International / NEWROCK INTERNATIONAL LIMITED
Developer country · App ID 6470980051
British Virgin Islands

Current German and Irish Apple provider panels identify NEWROCK INTERNATIONAL LIMITED, DUNS 815502705, Road Town, British Virgin Islands. E3; E4. This is the declared provider location, not an operational or nationality finding.

App Store listing ↗
App ID, version and other identifiers
App Store ID
6470980051
Bundle identifier
com.newrock.chatminimac
Version
1.0.66 / build 66
First released
2023-11-06

What the controlled test actually captured.

A fourth, clearer test asked the app directly for its exact model. The visible answer claims GPT-6.2 Sol. The observed request prefix contains that question, model gpt-6-luna and the Sol identity instruction. A valid completed response recovered during this test contains the same visible answer and model gpt-6-luna. The first three prompts were harmless marker tests; this fourth question demonstrates the effect of the identity instruction.

The Terminal screenshots at the opening display selected fields from saved captures after credentials and session attribution were omitted. They are documentary views of extracted data, not original unfiltered Frida output or a proxy user interface. The original app screenshots, source logs and full recovered response event are retained privately. The server label beside the reply comes from the request Host, not from an invented response header. A global memory scan is not a complete packet capture or an authenticated socket-to-buffer map.

This Mac app is built with Flutter. Its network transport uses TLS encryption. The evidence below came from readable data inside the app’s own process memory during controlled transmission and response handling. We did not decrypt a packet capture, disable TLS checks or redirect the traffic through a proxy.

The app shows GPT-6.2 Sol as the selected model. In the complete request recovered while that selection was active, the model field is gpt-6-luna. The same request adds a system message telling the AI: “Your model identity is GPT-6.2 Sol.” A later paragraph instructs it to identify itself as GPT-6.2 Sol when asked about its model. These are the app’s instructions, not an answer we persuaded the chatbot to invent.

The first test’s completed response also reports gpt-6-luna. The two later tests recovered complete requests with the same Luna model field while the interface continued to show Sol. This is direct evidence that the tested free mode presents a different model identity to the user from the one it requests from its relay. Apple should examine that mismatch before buyers rely on the advertised model names.

The test used harmless prompts in anonymous guest mode. No subscription was purchased, and no premium model was tested. The relay’s own metadata does not independently authenticate which provider or model it runs upstream. The captured instruction to claim a different identity is itself a misleading-presentation concern.

The app offered anonymous access without Apple ID. We entered three harmless marker prompts and then one direct model-identity question; all received replies. During TLS writes, a read-only observer recovered the original HTTP header blocks and the complete JSON bodies for tests 02 and 03. Each complete body matches the corresponding captured prefix, and its UTF-8 byte count matches the original Content-Length: 6,746 and 6,918 bytes respectively.

Test 03 sends the previous test conversation as input together with the new message and a system instruction asserting the Sol identity. It also includes image-generation and document-generation tool definitions. These show what was sent to the relay; they do not prove those tools work or that the relay retains the conversation.

The first test yielded a valid response.completed event with model gpt-6-luna, a completed status and token-use fields. For test 03, the matching final text and final stream events were recovered, but initial response headers and a complete response.completed event were not. We do not join unrelated headers to the answer or claim a complete packet capture.

The supplied Flutter bypass script was inspected but not applied: it used a fixed proxy address and an Intel-specific search. Read-only observation recovered the relevant plaintext from the running process without changing certificate checks or routing. Model values, prompts, entitlement checks and payment logic were not changed.

The live paywall calls its offer “Get GPT-5 Plus” while promising GPT-6.2 Sol and Astra. The screenshot records the test VM’s regional prices; the US and Irish store prices remain listed separately. No upgrade was bought, so delivery of premium models and file-upload features is untested.

Actual live app-window excerpt: Sol is selected; Sol Ultrafast and Astra require an upgrade. The excerpt retains the original selected pixels. E28; E33.
Actual live app-window excerpt: Sol is selected; Sol Ultrafast and Astra require an upgrade. The excerpt retains the original selected pixels. E28; E33.
Actual live subscription offer in the test VM: “Get GPT-5 Plus”, Sol/Astra promises and the displayed regional prices. No purchase was made. E28; E33.
Actual live subscription offer in the test VM: “Get GPT-5 Plus”, Sol/Astra promises and the displayed regional prices. No purchase was made. E28; E33.
Reproduced free-mode observations and their limits
EvidenceObserved result
Capture methodRead-only process-memory observation in the macOS VM. TLS stayed enabled; no request, model or payment edits.
Selected user-facing modelGPT-6.2 Sol
Complete requests · tests 02 and 03model: gpt-6-luna · stream: true · reasoning effort: low
Relay routePOST /more/v1/responses · host live.minichatclub.net:80 · TLS records observed; the port number is not evidence of unencrypted traffic.
System instructionYour model identity is GPT-6.2 Sol.
Completed responses · tests 01 and 04Valid response.completed events report model gpt-6-luna and status completed. Test 04 includes the same “I am GPT-6.2 Sol…” text shown in the app.
Conversation contentPrior user/assistant test turns and the new prompt are sent in input. Retention is not established.
Not testedPaid tiers, upstream provider authentication, external checkout and server retention.

E28–E33. Raw captures remain private; public panels omit credentials and device/session identifiers.

The OpenAI request appears in both apps’ own histories.

The Mac 1.0.40 and iPhone 1.1.29 releases dated 13 October 2025 state: “Due to the Openai copyright holder’s request to modify the relevant content”. This is a direct, dated statement by the publisher on Apple’s pages.

The statement supports a reported prior rights-related intervention. It does not identify which elements were changed, establish that OpenAI approved the current subtitle, or prove an Apple account suspension.

Rendered extraction of the same release-history note from the Mac and iPhone Apple pages, with exact versions and dates. The underlying private notice was not obtained. E2; E6.
Rendered extraction of the same release-history note from the Mac and iPhone Apple pages, with exact versions and dates. The underlying private notice was not obtained. E2; E6.

E1 pages 5–6; E2; E6.

“Data Not Collected” meets a policy describing collection.

The Apple label says no data is collected. The linked Google Doc, written in Chinese and naming MINIAIgpt, says the service may collect and use device/keychain information and IP addresses, including for account-owner records and internal analysis. Those are English summaries of the original clauses, not claims that every Keychain item is read.

The same policy refers to WeChat and another product name. It does not give an app-specific explanation of the chat-service hosts found in the supplied binary, which AI provider handles prompts, or how long remote account and usage records are retained.

Apple excludes transient data needed only to service a request from its definition of collection. The stronger finding is the unresolved policy/label inconsistency around account records and analysis, not the mere presence of networking. Actual server retention was not measured.

The privacy, subscription and support documents are hosted on Google Docs, a service offering free personal document hosting. No independent product-presentation website is listed in the observed store record. This weakens the available service explanation; using Google Docs alone does not prove fraud.

Original Apple privacy-label wording alongside clearly labelled English summaries of the linked Chinese policy. This is an evidence extraction panel; the complete original policy capture remains in the appended source dossier. E1; E2; E7.
Original Apple privacy-label wording alongside clearly labelled English summaries of the linked Chinese policy. This is an evidence extraction panel; the complete original policy capture remains in the appended source dossier. E1; E2; E7.
Exact privacy document linked by the developer

E2; E7–E9; E16; E18.

What the supplied Mac program actually contains.

The native launcher is a Flutter application. Its main Dart program is in App.framework, which was inspected separately from the launcher and the general Flutter engine. The signed app has native purchase, local database, secure-storage and Apple sign-in components; it is not established to be a simple WebView wrapper.

The payload identifies the minichatclub and chatdogai service family. The VM test now confirms active connections in that family and recovers complete requests to live.minichatclub.net:80/more/v1/responses. This is a third-party relay, not an OpenAI-owned address. A relay can use OpenAI upstream; its presence alone is not a breach.

The separate unauthenticated app-profile route returned an encoded envelope. That envelope was not decrypted offline. A read-only scan of the running app recovered its already-decoded active configuration, including model labels and identity instructions. No embedded credential was used outside the app to make a separate API request.

Configuration includes payment-route fields. The observed live offer used the app’s subscription presentation; an external checkout was not tested. Shipped or configured payment markers alone do not prove a prohibited payment flow.

Read-only extraction from the actual Flutter App.framework payload. Exact universal-file offsets and hash are provided. These are compiled literals, not a network capture or decompiled source-code claim. E18.
Read-only extraction from the actual Flutter App.framework payload. Exact universal-file offsets and hash are provided. These are compiled literals, not a network capture or decompiled source-code claim. E18.
How to verify the supplied binary
ItemRecorded value
App and versionChatBot.5.0.app · 1.0.66 / build 66
Bundle / signing teamcom.newrock.chatminimac · QXNV8KJ67S
Signature checkcodesign --verify --deep --strict passed
Main Dart payloadContents/Frameworks/App.framework/Versions/A/App
Dart payload SHA-25643811a88df21aee764427eec6f5e713476c5a30f7cf8f1a960688e746b90c446
Archive SHA-2568e866bd99784a583130572b4acca2e9b59d34f1f8b61a4d9f2009eb293836ffa
Test scopeStatic inspection plus four free guest prompts in an isolated macOS VM. Read-only Frida observation; no TLS, request, model, payment or entitlement modifications. No purchase or Apple-ID sign-in.

E17; E18; E20; E28–E33.

The live mismatch is stronger than a list of model names.

The live menu advertises GPT-6.2 Sol, GPT-6.2 Sol Ultrafast and GPT-6.2 Astra. Ultrafast and Astra show Upgrade buttons. The free option was Sol throughout the controlled tests. Complete requests from tests 02 and 03 explicitly use gpt-6-luna, and include a system message that tells the model to claim the Sol identity. This is the observed mismatch; premium delivery was not checked.

The fourth test demonstrates the practical effect: asked for its exact model, the app answers GPT-6.2 Sol, while its completed response event reports gpt-6-luna. The answer alone is not model authentication; the instruction in the request and the different model field are the stronger evidence. E34.

The active profile also holds separate instructions that tell the AI to identify as Sol Ultrafast and Astra. Those configuration contents do not establish which backend model a paying user receives. They explain why asking this chatbot “Which model are you?” cannot authenticate the service: the client is already giving it an identity script.

The subtitle, description and promotions tell different model stories as well. Current official OpenAI documentation includes GPT-6-family models; this report does not claim those families are invented or that an independent chatbot cannot use an API.

E2; E13; E18; E28–E33.

Paid-access and support complaints are repeated.

The US Mac feed contains 29 entries and the Spanish Mac feed returns 50; these are feed samples, not overall rating counts. The source feeds include positive accounts of useful answers and easy use as well as the complaints below.

The strongest branding complaint is the Spanish reviewer who says they mistook the app for the official product. Other complaints concern paid access, quota and support. They warrant a current purchase-flow check; they do not establish fraudulent transactions or a measured failure rate.

Selected attributed review reports, with dates
Product / dateWhat the reviewer reports
Mac · ES · 29 May 2025Subscribed thinking the app was official; discovered it was third party and could not use web ChatGPT. English summary/translation.
Mac · ES · 14 October 2025Paid for a year but still saw the free version; contact attempts went unanswered. English summary.
Mac · US · 7 June 2026Reports unsuitable photo-editing output and a support-email delivery failure after paying for a yearly plan.
Mac · US · 10 May 2026Reports an insufficient_quota error after spending about $30.
Mac · US · 7 February 2025Reports that a subscription was not honoured and support did not answer.
iPhone · US · 10 March 2026Reports paid subscription access was not unlocked.

E10–E12; E22.

The public company identity points to the British Virgin Islands.

The German and Irish provider panels name NEWROCK INTERNATIONAL LIMITED, DUNS 815502705, as a declared trader in Road Town, British Virgin Islands. That is app-specific business-location evidence and is the country used for this report.

A mainland-China telephone country code, a Chinese-language policy and a development-path account marker are additional operational clues. They do not identify a director, beneficial owner or a separate Apple account. A mailbox label containing “uk” does not establish UK incorporation.

Search results also contain older companies with the same name in unrelated business contexts. Without a matching registration identifier, this report does not assign their directors, shareholders or past business activities to this app seller.

E3; E4; E7; E17; E18.

What was found about other accounts.

The direct Apple account connection is the Mac/iPhone pair. An exact additional App Store URL, ID 6553969181, is present in the supplied payload, but current checked lookups return no product and the US route returns 404. A missing target cannot identify its former seller or prove an Apple suspension.

An external first-hand investigation reports the minichatclub/chatdogai domain family in CoreMind’s Gemix. We verified those domains in Newrock’s supplied payload and independently checked Apple’s Gemix identity: app 6756475480, CoreMind Innovations LTD., developer 1860784465. We did not receive the Gemix binary, and its current legal documents use a different support identity. The reported infrastructure overlap remains a lead for a counterpart comparison.

The Newrock markers were also compared with 18 prior supplied archives, covering 50 distinct native/Dart code payloads. No exact match was found in that corpus. Generic Flutter libraries, hosted legal documents or similar model wording are not used as proof of a shared owner.

CoreMind Apple account · reported lead, not proven common owner Gemix · counterpart mentioned in the external investigation External first-hand Gemix investigation · 21 October 2026

E18; E19; E24; E26; E27.

The supplied store captures, preserved separately.

These original images were extracted from the supplied dossier’s US and Irish page captures. The appended dossier also retains the original capture of the Chinese-language privacy document. Their dates are the supplied snapshot date, not a newly executed app session.

Open all original supplied store captures
Original supplied store capture from Supplied dossier page 8. Source snapshot: 19 November 2026, 16:08:26 UTC. E1.
Original supplied store capture from Supplied dossier page 8. Source snapshot: 19 November 2026, 16:08:26 UTC. E1.
Original supplied store capture from Supplied dossier page 9. Source snapshot: 19 November 2026, 16:08:26 UTC. E1.
Original supplied store capture from Supplied dossier page 9. Source snapshot: 19 November 2026, 16:08:26 UTC. E1.
Original supplied store capture from Supplied dossier page 10. Source snapshot: 19 November 2026, 16:08:26 UTC. E1.
Original supplied store capture from Supplied dossier page 10. Source snapshot: 19 November 2026, 16:08:26 UTC. E1.
Original supplied store capture from Supplied dossier page 11. Source snapshot: 19 November 2026, 16:08:26 UTC. E1.
Original supplied store capture from Supplied dossier page 11. Source snapshot: 19 November 2026, 16:08:26 UTC. E1.

E1 pages 8–12.

View the dates and timeline
  1. Mac app released

    First release date in Apple’s exact-ID lookup. E23.

  2. iPhone companion released

    Separate bundle com.newrock.chatminiios under the same Apple account. E5; E23.

  3. Mac name and screenshots updated

    Release 1.0.25 explicitly records a name/screenshot update; the earlier artwork itself was not recovered. E1; E2.

  4. Official-app confusion reported

    Spanish Mac review says the buyer subscribed believing the app was official. E11; E22.

  5. Both apps report a rights-holder change request

    Mac 1.0.40 and iPhone 1.1.29 carry the same OpenAI-related change note. The notice is not independently verified. E2; E6.

  6. Supplied Mac version released

    Current and supplied Mac build 1.0.66 / 66. E2; E17.

  7. Listing and binary investigation

    Successful current listings, legal documents, review feeds and read-only inspection of the supplied signed app. E2–E24.

  8. Controlled live VM tests

    Four controlled free guest prompts. Complete requests recovered for tests 02 and 03; a direct model-identity question in Test 04 produces a Sol claim while its request prefix and completed response report gpt-6-luna. E28–E35.

CHECK THE SOURCES

The records behind this report.

The prepared dossier combines this investigation with every page of the supplied 12-page analysis. Current HTTP evidence is dated separately. Original source screenshots can contain non-English text and the developer’s visible business contact details; the report supplies English explanations.

Open source files, archive links and checksums

E1 / Supplied 12-page App Store analysis

ai-chatbot-ai-pro-assistant_6470980051_2026-11-19_180826_analysis.pdf. All 12 pages retained in the prepared dossier. Original capture: 19 November 2026, 16:08:26 UTC. The automated icon percentages are not used as a copying verdict.

SHA-256: 544a82fee07eba3c49a11c8dcaeec5c31f883e1d543c75792e2282fb9700dbcf

E2 / Current US Mac listing

Successful current Apple page: subtitle, description, privacy declaration, purchase labels and version history.

Open source ↗

SHA-256: eeabcb7826a0d635f791271e14ff0ae75ea36c51ba086f95c956adf5ceed9a88

E3 / Current German Mac listing

Successful Apple provider disclosure: NEWROCK INTERNATIONAL LIMITED, DUNS 815502705, Road Town, British Virgin Islands; declared trader.

Open source ↗

SHA-256: d5cc2448364556eae32056bfe4cba85654ecc291a9855d91628743156854c1af

E4 / Current Irish Mac listing

Successful Apple provider disclosure and euro purchase labels.

Open source ↗

SHA-256: 110f8144c82516e578744424a095464ab04d39b41339c6d20da30dd822055c81

E5 / Current Apple developer catalog

Apple returns the Mac and iPhone apps under developer 1672772882. Catalog membership directly verifies the account connection.

Open source ↗

SHA-256: 99e51c26852cf4f8583475abc6cfe77db5ddb05af9bd067a72c515b330e92892

E6 / Current US iPhone listing

Companion app 6471813468; same subtitle, legal links, privacy label and seller. Its version history repeats the reported OpenAI change request.

Open source ↗

SHA-256: 7f4f5c982835e52331eee8dab95112b21fe3904921ec6abd4eb59fa6f07d6fb8

E7 / Linked Chinese-language privacy policy

Google Docs text export. English passages in this report are labelled translations/summaries. The policy names MINIAIgpt and describes device/keychain information, IP addresses, account records and internal analysis; it also mentions WeChat and another product name.

Open source ↗

SHA-256: a34261b6f0d2f871a239acd755e2b39526cd9b1ec27ac82919a20e7905ab69c0

E8 / Linked subscription terms

Google Docs export: short Chinese-language auto-renewal and cancellation instructions, not a complete AI-service or model explanation.

Open source ↗

SHA-256: a8b130619e65af88a30f031ceba45c605964c3495be0ed428e841e603671b8b7

E9 / Linked technical support page

Google Docs text export promises support around the clock and provides an email contact.

Open source ↗

SHA-256: cce4b20a1880b63edcc97f15a7e38db9430f1a69632331415cd74e4799fec76c

E10 / US Mac customer-review feed

29 review entries returned. Includes positive reviews and dated subscription, quota and bounced-support-email complaints. These are reviewer reports, not reproduced transactions.

Open source ↗

SHA-256: c1a590454217dd3643cecbcca5979a45ed1102e36ce57e40b0e9148a9b211635

E11 / Spanish Mac customer-review feed

50 review entries returned. Review 12711859345, 29 May 2025, says the buyer subscribed thinking the app was official and could not use the web ChatGPT subscription. English excerpt is explicitly translated.

Open source ↗

SHA-256: b4d7b9a5d19a4ed52a3c1d02bdd601b7393f57c1a1ee75be26ee1acf4efe3224

E12 / US iPhone customer-review feed

16 entries returned, including positive reviews and a 10 March 2026 complaint that a paid subscription did not unlock access.

Open source ↗

SHA-256: 8ecef30b5a18a79cfae4316311e7955d976b128f65af70f369181c9707b88729

E13 / Current official OpenAI model catalog

Current official reference includes GPT-6-family models. This report does not call every GPT-6 reference invented. The initial catalog comparison was followed by controlled runtime tests documented in E28–E35.

Open source ↗

SHA-256: e0037b081dd821903ddb620f582ce24dc20f8dee8c4120705e83ad17614563f5

E14 / OpenAI brand guidance

Official guidance checked on 19 November 2026: API/model references must be precise and accurate; marks must not be more prominent than the developer’s own branding. Its separate app-title restriction is not presented as a blanket subtitle ban. No private rights notice or licence was obtained.

Open source ↗

E15 / Apple App Review Guidelines

Current official metadata, privacy, intellectual-property and purchase rules. Rule 2.3.7 was rechecked on 19 November 2026: it addresses trademark stuffing to game discovery and references to other apps in subtitles.

Open source ↗

SHA-256: dc640645f4875c00e53a8c4b7afc4370893eb42439becd7e940ba200d0add112

E16 / Apple privacy-label definitions

Apple distinguishes retained off-device collection from transient processing needed to service a request. The finding here is the published policy/label discrepancy, not an inference that every network request is collection.

Open source ↗

SHA-256: 60b043ec74c0c009782e8b6c4c6124bd16ae82221295b110597dc273e32e2f01

E17 / Supplied signed Mac application

ChatBot.5.0.zip; bundle com.newrock.chatminimac; version 1.0.66/build 66; signing team QXNV8KJ67S; deep strict signature verification passed. Static inspection only. No app launch, sign-in, purchase or use of embedded authentication material.

SHA-256: 8e866bd99784a583130572b4acca2e9b59d34f1f8b61a4d9f2009eb293836ffa

E18 / Flutter application payload: exact literal locations

ChatBot.5.0.app/Contents/Frameworks/App.framework/Versions/A/App, universal ARM64/x86_64. Shipped literals identify pro.minichatclub.net, live.minichatclub.net:80, app.chatdogai.com, config/profile/mac/chatmini, chat/newchat, more/v1/responses, model strings and payment/configuration markers. These are file-byte locations, not a captured network trace. No provider credentials are published.

SHA-256: 43811a88df21aee764427eec6f5e713476c5a30f7cf8f1a960688e746b90c446

E19 / Comparison with prior supplied binaries

18 prior ZIP archives, including nested archives; 50 distinct native/Dart application code payloads inspected without read errors. No match for the tested Newrock signing-team marker, service domains, support markers or exact app IDs. This is a bounded corpus check, not a claim about all App Store accounts.

E20 / Public app-profile configuration response

One unauthenticated GET of the exact literal-derived route returned HTTP 200 with an encoded content envelope. No client credentials were used, no account was created and no chat or payment operation was requested. Encoded content was not decrypted; that initial unauthenticated probe did not verify active settings. The later running-app observations are documented separately in E28–E32.

Open source ↗

SHA-256: cd368292e7754b95404a4c4c62018a915c4e6b0e4bd94f3b989d1acd4ae6ce13

E21 / Service-domain registry records

Current Verisign RDAP records for chatdogai.com and minichatclub.net retained privately. Domain registration and common hosting do not establish the owner of another Apple account.

Open source ↗

E22 / Spanish Mac product page

Current successful primary Apple response corroborates the official-app confusion review and its date.

Open source ↗

SHA-256: d7fd9e0bcddf98ab4e5470d83f0adb6819151d54c16d3fae25eefbdc0c8a08dd

E23 / Primary product and official reference lookup

Exact Apple numeric IDs and bundle/seller identities. The unresolved outbound ID 6553969181 is absent from this US response.

Open source ↗

SHA-256: dac5d0dfc24e17213dfd68a73cace8931594d8b84dabd95cfdce9907b8af7526

E24 / Unresolved outbound App Store link

The supplied Dart payload contains https://apps.apple.com/app/id6553969181. Current exact-ID US/DE/IE lookups returned no product and the named US route returned 404. Product name, publisher, previous availability and the reason are unresolved; this is not a verified suspended account.

Open source ↗

E25 / ChatGPT and API billing are separate

Current official OpenAI Help Center article read on 19 November 2026. API-platform billing and ChatGPT subscription billing are separate; an independent seller’s subscription is not evidence of an OpenAI ChatGPT subscription.

Open source ↗

E26 / Reported Gemix infrastructure lead

First-hand external investigation dated 21 October 2026 reports minichatclub/chatdogai-family infrastructure in CoreMind’s Gemix. This report independently verifies the hosts in Newrock’s supplied payload and Gemix’s current Apple identity only; the claimed matching Gemix implementation was not reproduced. This remains a reported technical lead, not established common ownership.

Open source ↗

E27 / Gemix exact-ID Apple lookup

Apple identifies Gemix - Gem AI Assistant, 6756475480, bundle com.coremind.gemai, developer CoreMind Innovations LTD., 1860784465. A counterpart binary was not supplied for this investigation.

Open source ↗

SHA-256: 07eed848201a940d2ec31e648a311e04544ac2380d48fe71372e59c297e5d8af

E28 / Controlled macOS VM session

Three free guest prompts in version 1.0.66/build 66 on macOS 26.2 arm64. Original UI captures retained privately; selected app-window excerpts reproduced. No purchase, Apple-ID sign-in, TLS bypass, request edits or entitlement edits.

SHA-256: fd23ccae84f1e411d94da1d79fe3cfc7fefd2c3b4ff67d8d46d43547f8a1064b

E29 / Active profile recovered from running app

A read-only heap scan recovered the active decoded profile. name_gpt35 is GPT-6.2 Sol, chat_mode is gpt-6-luna, and separate system instructions assert Sol, Sol Ultrafast and Astra identities. Credential values remain private.

SHA-256: 0e54a8bc1d604ef2e7f1cb1f3a05d21c38a02c9a2833a5131817da3464eb3972

E30 / Complete Test 02 request

Observed HTTP header block and matching complete JSON body recovered at TLS write. POST /more/v1/responses, host live.minichatclub.net:80. Body 6746 UTF-8 bytes matches Content-Length. model gpt-6-luna; system instruction asserts Sol.

SHA-256: 10444f85664912e239f6e8eed0c887d7709c9272fec3f63bb23701aa1e25685a

E31 / Complete Test 03 request

Observed header block and matching complete JSON body recovered at TLS write. Body 6918 UTF-8 bytes matches Content-Length and the captured body prefix. UI still displays Sol; model gpt-6-luna, history and system identity instruction present.

SHA-256: d43e56c9474b8449b12bbffb2d925032c4c729cfb2f1e74271dae6d0569946d3

E32 / First test completed-response event

Valid recovered response.completed JSON from the first test reports gpt-6-luna, status completed and the first test marker. It is separately identified from the later request captures. This is relay metadata, not independent upstream authentication.

SHA-256: c4c0aca346e71ec26e57cf579b52ba883f13f1a6c8434a8ab06ccfffb5b4d1d6

E33 / Original live screenshot and crop provenance

Private original screenshots of the live paywall, model menu and controlled chat. Public app-window excerpts have documented crop rectangles and pixel equality checks; no reconstructed UI or loading overlays.

SHA-256: d2d61bf06651ad2a017df08884af1c38248f5659ac864eab57e714f013d2e734

E34 / Test 04 · model question, request prefix and completed response

A controlled free guest question asks for the exact model. The UI claims Sol. The request Host is live.minichatclub.net:80; its recovered body prefix includes the exact question, gpt-6-luna and the Sol identity instruction. A valid response.completed event contains the same Sol reply and model gpt-6-luna. Initial response headers and the complete request body were not recovered for this test. The server context is sourced to the request Host; no socket-to-buffer or upstream identity authentication is claimed.

SHA-256: d7098c26906fc61d1158c79618929e73890331f138b19b2d9afff41508cbf2a5

E35 / Test 04 · app and Terminal screenshot provenance

Original app screenshots show the full typed question and complete answer. Two Terminal screenshots display prepared source excerpts from saved observed memory data, with their scope explicitly labelled. Crop coordinates, original and public SHA-256 values, and pixel-equality checks are retained. Shell prompts and unrelated desktop material are excluded from public crops.

SHA-256: 80321a31ee450ecbbd2dcf074acecdfde2f9ef5a0df1b3b7a1794376925886cb

E36 / OpenAI · Sign in with ChatGPT integration documentation

Official documentation reviewed on 19 November 2026. Authorized third-party ChatGPT integrations exist and involve ChatGPT sign-in/plan authorization. This prevents a blanket technical-impossibility claim. No such flow was observed in the controlled Newrock guest tests.

Open source ↗